Moderator: Andrew
escapefan wrote:cinkidd wrote:One of the best things that Steve could do for up and coming singers is to come out and admit that he lost his voice and explain WHY he lost his voice.
Rich the Lost Guy
I agree, but I just don't see him doing it.
cinkidd wrote:One of the best things that Steve could do for up and coming singers is to come out and admit that he lost his voice and explain WHY he lost his voice.
Rich the Lost Guy
kmd2009 wrote:who cares if he can't sing anymore! just enjoy what he did sang for us over the years, also he's still healthy and its not like he's dead. leave the guy alone and let him enjoy what he has.
kmd2009 wrote:who cares if he can't sing anymore! just enjoy what he did sang for us over the years, also he's still healthy and its not like he's dead. leave the guy alone and let him enjoy what he has.
cinkidd wrote:kmd2009 wrote:who cares if he can't sing anymore! just enjoy what he did sang for us over the years, also he's still healthy and its not like he's dead. leave the guy alone and let him enjoy what he has.
Most of use truly enjoy what he did and how he did it. But the sad fact of the matter is that he is the one keeping "hope" alive by not answering questions directly. If he would all of this "rumor" and fantasy belief that he will one day reunite with Journey and or put out another CD of music would go away. We then really could focus on how great he was and what a miracle it was to be witness to it. He needs to put it to rest once and for all.
Rich the Another Guy
Memorex wrote:cinkidd wrote:kmd2009 wrote:who cares if he can't sing anymore! just enjoy what he did sang for us over the years, also he's still healthy and its not like he's dead. leave the guy alone and let him enjoy what he has.
Most of use truly enjoy what he did and how he did it. But the sad fact of the matter is that he is the one keeping "hope" alive by not answering questions directly. If he would all of this "rumor" and fantasy belief that he will one day reunite with Journey and or put out another CD of music would go away. We then really could focus on how great he was and what a miracle it was to be witness to it. He needs to put it to rest once and for all.
Rich the Another Guy
Who knows what future possibilities there are? Maybe a new type of surgery, maybe a different style of singing. You can't expect someone to know the future.
cinkidd wrote:Memorex wrote:cinkidd wrote:kmd2009 wrote:who cares if he can't sing anymore! just enjoy what he did sang for us over the years, also he's still healthy and its not like he's dead. leave the guy alone and let him enjoy what he has.
Most of use truly enjoy what he did and how he did it. But the sad fact of the matter is that he is the one keeping "hope" alive by not answering questions directly. If he would all of this "rumor" and fantasy belief that he will one day reunite with Journey and or put out another CD of music would go away. We then really could focus on how great he was and what a miracle it was to be witness to it. He needs to put it to rest once and for all.
Rich the Another Guy
Who knows what future possibilities there are? Maybe a new type of surgery, maybe a different style of singing. You can't expect someone to know the future.
I'm not talking about the future, I'm talking about his current reality.
Let's not forget that the man is in his early sixties and any surgery at this point in time or the future is a major risk and does not guarantee the quality of voice that he would like to have.
Rich the Future Guy
TRAGChick wrote:cinkidd wrote:Memorex wrote:cinkidd wrote:kmd2009 wrote:who cares if he can't sing anymore! just enjoy what he did sang for us over the years, also he's still healthy and its not like he's dead. leave the guy alone and let him enjoy what he has.
Most of use truly enjoy what he did and how he did it. But the sad fact of the matter is that he is the one keeping "hope" alive by not answering questions directly. If he would all of this "rumor" and fantasy belief that he will one day reunite with Journey and or put out another CD of music would go away. We then really could focus on how great he was and what a miracle it was to be witness to it. He needs to put it to rest once and for all.
Rich the Another Guy
Who knows what future possibilities there are? Maybe a new type of surgery, maybe a different style of singing. You can't expect someone to know the future.
I'm not talking about the future, I'm talking about his current reality.
Let's not forget that the man is in his early sixties and any surgery at this point in time or the future is a major risk and does not guarantee the quality of voice that he would like to have.
Rich the Future Guy
So - how did Steven Tyler get his voice back...?
From my experience, Singng is very much a Psychological, as well as a Physical, thing:
2 examples of how people's "heads" can get in their way:
1. Meat Loaf - as stated by him in his BTM, and
2. Shania Twain - the stress of her personal life pretty much "paralyzed" her from performing.
Steven Tyler had that surgery; he's OLDER than Steve - he's 63 & has a new Song out!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BM39ya_-XQM
cinkidd wrote:One of the best things that Steve could do for up and coming singers is to come out and admit that he lost his voice and explain WHY he lost his voice.
Rich the Lost Guy
steveo777 wrote:If I went mountain climbing or tried to sing for any duration and I wasn't in shape for it I'd be having some
physical discomfort too. Self confidence comes from doing and positive reinforcement, maybe even some
coaching. I believe that state of mind determines most actions and most outcomes. I question whether
reclusiveness is not feeding depression which feeds upon depression and leads to further isolation?
Shit....here I go. I think we've all analyzed this to death. Only Steve knows what Steve is doing and going through.
Andrew wrote:cinkidd wrote:One of the best things that Steve could do for up and coming singers is to come out and admit that he lost his voice and explain WHY he lost his voice.
Rich the Lost Guy
It's not lost.....it just isn't what it used to be and Steve being the perfectionist, doesn't have the confidence to move forward. Plus there's the issue about physical discomfort when singing for any length of time.
Andrew wrote:cinkidd wrote:One of the best things that Steve could do for up and coming singers is to come out and admit that he lost his voice and explain WHY he lost his voice.
Rich the Lost Guy
It's not lost.....it just isn't what it used to be and Steve being the perfectionist, doesn't have the confidence to move forward. Plus there's the issue about physical discomfort when singing for any length of time.
Tito wrote:Andrew wrote:cinkidd wrote:One of the best things that Steve could do for up and coming singers is to come out and admit that he lost his voice and explain WHY he lost his voice.
Rich the Lost Guy
It's not lost.....it just isn't what it used to be and Steve being the perfectionist, doesn't have the confidence to move forward. Plus there's the issue about physical discomfort when singing for any length of time.
Don't try putting the shit back in the horse.
BTW, Steve Perry - Fuck him.
Andrew wrote:cinkidd wrote:One of the best things that Steve could do for up and coming singers is to come out and admit that he lost his voice and explain WHY he lost his voice.
Rich the Lost Guy
It's not lost.....it just isn't what it used to be and Steve being the perfectionist, doesn't have the confidence to move forward.
Plus there's the issue about physical discomfort when singing for any length of time.
cinkidd wrote:One of the best things that Steve could do for up and coming singers is to come out and admit that he lost his voice and explain WHY he lost his voice.
Rich the Lost Guy
Pacfanweb wrote:cinkidd wrote:One of the best things that Steve could do for up and coming singers is to come out and admit that he lost his voice and explain WHY he lost his voice.
Rich the Lost Guy
I agree, and then maybe he'd be more confident to go ahead with singing in whatever key he can manage now.
All singers lose something to Father Time. Even very blessed singers who can still hit most of the notes from their younger days have at least had the tone of their voices change. Sammy Hagar is a great example of that. His voice is rougher a lot of the time than it was in his youth, yet he still has the majority of his range. Then you have dudes like Elton John, who went from a tenor to a baritone because of surgery....and he just adapted, and sings everything much lower now. And still sells out everywhere. Perry could do that...sing in a range that's comfortable to him.
I'd like, for just once, see someone interview Perry and point blank ask what range he has now. And then inform him that even though we all know he is such a critic of his own sound, there are thousands of fans who don't care....they just want to hear him sing again, with whatever he has left. If it truly is a train wreck, so be it....at least TRY. Go out and do a Garth Brooks thing...do a show on the weekends in Vegas. Sing for a half an hour or so....you don't need to do it for 3 hours. Just try. Or straight up tell people you can't.
Six years ago, he provided some vocals on a David Pack song. He sounded pretty good on it, even though it was only a few lines here and there.....but the voice DOES still sound like Steve Perry. I doubt that much has changed since then.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests