Why no Cherone songs?

by **Mr.Rock** » Sun May 23, 2004 5:49 am

From Van Halen's official site;

THE VERY BEST OF VAN HALEN
POSTED 5/19/04

The band's forthcoming release, titled "The Very Best of Van Halen" will hit stores July 20! The two disc set features the following tracks, including three BRAND NEW tunes (not necessarily in this order):

Eruption, Ain't Talkin' 'bout Love, When It's Love, Finish What Ya Started,
You Really Got Me, Feels So Good, Jamie's Cryin', Black and Blue, Runnin' With the Devil, Poundcake, Beautiful Girls, Runaround, Dance the Night Away, Right Now, And the Cradle Will Rock..., Top of the World, Everybody Wants Some!!, Can't Stop Lovin' You, Unchained, Not Enough, Dancing in the Street, It's About Time (NEW!), Learning To See (NEW!), Up For Breakfast (NEW!), (Oh) Pretty Woman, Hot For Teacher, Jump, Panama, I'll Wait, Why Can't This Be Love, Dreams, Best of Both Worlds, Love Walks In, Ain't Talkin' 'bout Love (Live), Jump (Live), Panama (Live)

Is he (Cherone) being swept under the carpet?

by **Kenny** » Sun May 23, 2004 5:45 pm

Yeah I'm not sure I'm too happy about this album - I would have thought it might have been 'Best of - Vol II'.......instead it seems we are to get an entirely new best of.
Maybe it has something to do with new management, but now everyone who has 'Best of Vol I' will get a lot of the same songs in order to get the three new Sammy songs!

Not sure why no Cherone era Mr.Rock, I guess 'Without you' and 'Fire in the hole' could have been starters at least.
I'll still buy then bloody thing though!! :lol:

by **Bobbi Flekman** » Sun May 23, 2004 6:53 pm

That's always the trouble with compilations. The only reason for existence is to get to the bottom of your bank account. They're produced for a: the complete nu-B who doesn't know jack or b: the die-hard fan who wants to have everything ever done... If you fit the b-mold, be prepared to spend a lot of cash. Or just download the three new songs. Maybe that'll teach them (the record companies) to f*ck with the fans. release a new album! With all new songs!

by **NUBMAN** » Mon May 24, 2004 10:57 pm

This compilation is a blatant cash in. I dont know if the release of volume 2 would have been a problem legally??, but they certainly have enough great songs to make a volume 2 without repeating songs.
The fact that Cherone tunes are not on there shows that they are sweeping that era under the rug. If they dont acknowledge it, it doesnt exist. Those live versions are a joke. Why put live versions of songs that are already on this or the best of compilations? Its filler if you ask me.
The 3 songs better be killer. 6 years to write a few good tunes. I still get a funny feeling that we VH fans are laying bare chested, waiting for the VH corporate machine to take a big dump on our chest.

by **Kenny** » Mon May 24, 2004 11:09 pm

NUBMAN wrote:
This compilation is a blatant cash in. I dont know if the release of volume 2 would have been a problem legally??,
That's what I have been thinking......surely there can be no other reason for it.
The 3 songs better be killer. 6 years to write a few good tunes. I still get a funny feeling that we VH fans are laying bare chested, waiting for the VH corporate machine to take a big dump on our chest

Don't know if I like the analogy....... :lol:

by **Mr.Rock** » Tue May 25, 2004 1:06 am

I know its going to be a double CD, but I would have preferred them not to have repeated some of the songs that was on 'Volume I'. I think its taking the piss out of your average Van Halen fan.
What it boils down to is this, Will the new 3 songs be worth the price of a double CD? I hope so.
Like Nubman said, 6 years for 3 songs. :roll:

by **Kenny** » Tue May 25, 2004 1:14 am

Although those three songs are undoubtedly a teaser mate - Ed has said he has enough material for about 10 albums........exaggerations aside, I'm inclined to believe he has plenty more to offer.......

by **Mr.Rock** » Tue May 25, 2004 1:26 am

He may have 10 albums worth, but I'm assuming these 3 songs are the cream of the bunch. What is he gonna do if they're slagged off? We may never here the rest.

by **Kenny** » Tue May 25, 2004 1:34 am

Mr.Rock wrote:He may have 10 albums worth, but I'm assuming these 3 songs are the cream of the bunch. What is he gonna do if they're slagged off? We may never here the rest.

I'm not sure that's a sound assumption mate.
Be cool, we're getting some new VH material!!!

by **Mr.Rock** » Tue May 25, 2004 1:40 am

I hope you're right!

We may never here the rest.

I relly must lern to speel. :roll:

by **swwskj** » Fri May 28, 2004 10:43 am

A cash in?

Really, no shit?

That is what this whole reunion thing is. I only hope it last long enough for Eddie to "unleash" this musical constipation he has been suffering from.

Scott

by **Wayne** » Tue Jun 08, 2004 5:39 am

Gary Cherone of 80's rock band Extreme fame will be forgotten in VH history before too long for obvious reasons since he was an average fromtman despite being a great singer in his own right. VH3 will be forgotten in VH history as well even though I think it's a great album(I wouldn't buy it) if you're not expecting Van Halen, Fair Warning & 1984. The greatest hits compilation Best Of Both Worlds is just something for the record company to hype the Van Halen/Sammy Hagar reunion tour & to introduce this legendary rock band to the younger generation because the young people of today know Justin Timberlake more than Eddie.

by **Gaffguitars** » Fri Jun 11, 2004 7:23 am

Wayne wrote:Gary Cherone of 80's rock band Extreme fame will be forgotten in VH history before too long for obvious reasons since he was an average fromtman despite being a great singer in his own right. VH3 will be forgotten in VH history as well even though I think it's a great album(I wouldn't buy it) if you're not expecting Van Halen, Fair Warning & 1984. The greatest hits compilation Best Of Both Worlds is just something for the record company to hype the Van Halen/Sammy Hagar reunion tour & to introduce this legendary rock band to the younger generation because the young people of today know Justin Timberlake more than Eddie.

I agree. Except for III being a great album.

by **ltbob** » Sat Jun 12, 2004 6:43 am

Now that I have heard all three songs, all I got to say is thanks for the test drive, Im not buyin them. He has been playin the same old wore out crap on and on for 15-16 years, its not fresh. He sounds like a little kid in a music store 25 years ago tryin to sound like Ed Van Halen. Ed needs to hit the woodshed!! Good God Sammys guitar on all his latest records blow this crap away.
:idea:

Tired of makin excuses for B.S.
Lt.Bob

by **Metal Ed** » Tue Aug 10, 2004 2:19 pm

I don't care what anyone thinks, VHIII was a good cd. It was sure better than Diver Down. Gary is a major talent, but most fans are far to closeminded to try anything new or let a band grow.DAVE IS GONE!!!!
Suck it up and learn to deal.

Metal Ed

by **magicarpetride** » Sat Aug 14, 2004 6:36 pm

Gary is a little gayboy who didn't belong. Either Dave or Sammy as frontman of VH, no one else!

by **Wayne** » Sat Aug 14, 2004 11:22 pm

VH3 with Gary Cherone of Extreme fame as frontman of Van Halen is a forgotten album in VH history & by most of the fans while I thought Without You & Dirty Water Dog were alright but VH3 is a great rock album( I wouldn't buy it) if you're not expecting Van Halen, Fair Warning & 1984!

by **Kenny** » Sun Aug 15, 2004 12:26 am

Fucking weirdo.
Same shit, regurgitated yet again......no punctuation, no grammar, no brain.

by **YankeeRose** » Sun Oct 03, 2004 8:34 pm

I would have liked to see Dirty Water Dog on it. That is a great tune!

MR

Why no Cherone songs?

Why no Cherone songs?

not buyin it

Who is online