StocktontoMalone wrote:Ehwmatt wrote:StocktontoMalone wrote:Down 7 with 5 secs to go.....you score the TD. Do you kick the PAT, play for the tie(safe)? Or go for 2, play for the win(agressive)?
I would always play for the win......cause I wouldn't want to lose the coin toss in OT.
Or be that bonehead Buffalo head coach who defered the ball in OT.![]()
Regular season - Kick the pt
Playoff - Go for 2
Your thought process should be the same regardless if it is post season or regular season. IMHO. You got 16 games. Every game counts. As we saw this past Sunday night. You don't think there was alot riding on that regular season game?
It's admittedly a bit contradictory. Here's my thought process: Champions almost always require luck/balls/guts to win it all. In a playoff situation, I probably go for it... luck rewards the aggressor. I'm okay with losing homefield advantage to Peyton's greatness driving it 70 yards, maybe not so okay to putting it in his hands to end my season
Now, there are extenuating circumstances that can come into play in a playoff: If I'm coaching the 08-09 Steelers, I probably kick the point and assume my D can stop them and get us the ball even if we lose the coin toss. Same thought process in the opposite direction if my D is getting shredded like the Pats were at the end, if it's a playoff. Also, if it's a regular season game to determine the wild card, I might say fuck it and go for it if I don't think there's a good chance I can win otherwise.
There's no way you can make these kind of decisions in a hypothetical set in a vacuum, you know?