Eric wrote:Okay, so...100%...you don't think that Al Qaeda being drawn into Iraq and losing there helped take their eye off our homeland at all?
Possibly, tho it didn't seem to do the Brits or Spain alot of good.
I’d credit the wiretapping programs more than anything.
But that's not the point.
Iraq was sold as a grave danger, not a distraction.
Believing such an ulterior motive requires the administration to not only have been misleading about WMDs, but the quick occupation as well.
Grand conspiracies such as this, or the often suggested 'Iran through Iraq' one, just don’t add up.
By all accounts, Rumsfeld believed in a “light footprint” approach, and Generals that floated numbers for a long scale commitment, such as Shinseki, were dismissed.
Eric wrote:If you don't I fully respect your opinion after days of discussion...I just really feel that this indeed is what happened and we should trumpet the good (incuding Saddam being a terror sponsor and being dead) because our soldiers deserve it and I think it does tarnish what Al Qaeda accomplished 1993-2001. I don't say this with a partisan hat on at all...I firmly believe it.
As I’ve said before, Vietnam is now a tourist spot.
Is anyone truly thankful the ‘domino effect’ didn’t happen?
Does anyone really believe that wasn’t a costly mistake?
These incidental consequences are notable, but the steep cost of blood and treasure just overhangs everything.
Eric wrote:Good came out of Iraq despite their not being the WMD's that our (and many others) intelligence wrongly indicated.
I’m not going to get into the fact that France, Germany, Russia (and even our own CIA) expressed doubts about the intelligence, or the few shoeleather journalists in this country who spotted the fraud all along (McClatchey, Walter Pincus).
All that needs to be reiterated is that the UN Weapons Inspectors found scant nothing and Bush pulled them out.
For me, that speaks volumnes.
Throughout history, many wars have a casus belli that turn out to be iffy, but in this day and age of around-the clock-media such megalomaniacal deeds are ill advised.
I'm impressed they thought they could pull it off.