Memorex wrote:I remember them saying how bad it would be. I remember all the terrible warnings and all the end-of-world commentary. I remember Bush bailing everyone out. I didn't buy it then and I don't buy it now. And it's so funny how you talk about the collapse as if it wasn't almost entirely the housing market in which bad loans were pushed because of democrat policies. And republican policies.
That is not what I've said. And, you're wrong...that is NOT the 'entire' problem. People were applying for loans they knew they could not afford. They were at fault. Banks were making loans to people they knew could not pay. They were at fault. Those same banks then tried to offload the risk by brokering the risk. The banks were at fault again, as were the buyers who knew how high of a risk they were buying, and they did not have the assets to cover them if they went bad. But, they could combine such risk with the risk of other loans and then sell a package of high risk...and the buyer and seller were at fault again because they knew how much of a risk they were selling and buying and they did not have the assets to cover it. And, the auditors were at fault for not understanding how deep the systemic risk really was and how widespread...until the very end when TARP was first instituted and those first banks had NO CHOICE but to sign on to TARP or be declared insolvent by their auditors and go into bankruptcy.
You think the bail outs were great, I imagine. I don't.
No, I don't think they are 'great'. But, I think they were IMPOSSIBLE to avoid. Do you think Paulson 'liked' them? He stood up and gave a speech after Bear/Stearns and said that was it....no more bailouts. And, he let Lehman Brothers go into bankruptcy...which led to AIG because they held the risk of much of Lehman Brothers high risk loans. THAT was the problem. EVERY large bank would have FAILED...not just in the US, but worldwide. The economy would not just be in recession....there would be no economy.
Let it crumble. Let us pay for the bad decisions that were made. Let us suffer. And if that was allowed to occur, most agree it would have been for a shorter term.
That's just nuts. When banks worldwide start failing, people panic and pull money out. That is the Great Depression all over again. Even Paulson, a "let them fail" guy saw that. You can't let ever large bank in the world fail, causing consumers to lose trillions of dollars, and not expect anything other then a worldwide depression.
If things were better because of real growth, real jobs, good old US innovation, then we'd be sitting pretty good. But it's completely propped up. There is nothing there to support what's going on except for money being printed.
I just don't believe that's true at all.
There are more people on some type of government assistance now than ever before. The roles have exploded in the last 2 years. What do you see happening in America right now that will bring those millions of people back to the work force? What industry? What policy?
There should be cooperation to do things like getting us off of oil and into alternative energy. But, instead of cooperating, the two sides fight and NOTHING gets done. The Volt is a perfect example of that...instead of being constructive and offering useful critique...all they do is use it as a political tool...all the while imports are seeing the demand for alternative fuel cars and are going to squash the industry, just like they did in the 80's.
That's just one symbol of what the bigger issue is. It's like I said in another post, politics in the US is not about what is good for the country. It's about being reelected. There was no coming together for the greater good to get America back to work. It was all about taking Obama down, or taking the Republicans in congress down. Why do you think we talk about dogs on top of cars, and dogs for dinner? Because it's a lot easier to push the other side down for such things rather then building yourself up.
With Reagan and Clinton, I saw the spark of the next growth. You could see it, feel it. At this time, I honestly see nothing. Absolutely nothing. Not from Obama and not from Romney. Wherever you think we are today, there is nothing out there to put us back to where we were. And we've got an extra 5 trillion of debt just to keep things floating. Even I could pretend things are better by spending 5 trillion unearned dollars. Romney would probably equal that under our current conditions.
Of course there is no going back. We had a HUGE amount high risk credit floating around making a lot of huge corporations trillions of dollars. A huge part of our economy was being sustained by money that instantly taken away and replaced by TARP and government control.
Because I am headed to bed, I will answer the question as far as I see it. You and others like you need to stop pretending that we are some how in a much better place. You and others like you must hold Democrats responsible for the state of this country.
1
I'm sorry, but if you can't see how close we were to oblivion in 2008, then there is no hope for you. I think we would be in a situation worse then the great depression.
And, I'm not a Democrat nor a Republican.
Reagan brought folks together, Clinton brought folks together. That does not exist today. Class warfare will NEVER work. Partisan bullshit will never work. When you see what happens tomorrow, ask yourself how many independents will be pushed toward Romney because Obama generally supports the antics of the OWS crowd.
I would generally agree with this. But, that's the way politics is today.