MR

A Brit paper reports that her first single will be Wild Horses - and they posted a link to the Perez Hilton site.

http://perezhilton.com/2009-09-13-subo-does-the-stones



She sounds a bit too shrill for my taste.
And she makes it sound like it's from Les Miserables.

I think she sounds fantastic! Her "Le' Miz" style and sound is not unlike those of Celtic Women. She sounds like she has had vocal training and been singing professionally for years.... knowing that she hasn't...her natural gift of voice and ability is remarkable.

I'm w/you Susie~Q....shrill!!!
She has a beautiful voice, but I can only take so
much. I found myself becoming bored w/this one...
I like my Wild Horses with a bit of an edge!!!

Michigan Girl wrote:I'm w/you Susie~Q....shrill!!!
She has a beautiful voice, but I can only take so
much. I found myself becoming bored w/this one...
I like my Wild Horses with a bit of an edge!!!

Wonder who chose this song for her?
I think it's an unusual choice.

Blueskies wrote:I think she sounds fantastic! Her "Le' Miz" style and sound is not unlike those of Celtic Women. She sounds like she has had vocal training and been singing professionally for years.... knowing that she hasn't...her natural gift of voice and ability is remarkable.

I just don't hear that. Sorry.

For me, the Celtic Women [I have listened to them since Gunbot raved about them] have pure voices which are not shrill when they soar to those high notes.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ZRLraqXKQw

This sounds so much more beautiful to my ears.

It's GB's favourite LIsa Kelly by the way.

SusieP wrote:

Blueskies wrote:I think she sounds fantastic! Her "Le' Miz" style and sound is not unlike those of Celtic Women. She sounds like she has had vocal training and been singing professionally for years.... knowing that she hasn't...her natural gift of voice and ability is remarkable.

I just don't hear that. Sorry.

For me, the Celtic Women [I have listened to them since Gunbot raved about them] have pure voices which are not shrill when they soar to those high notes.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ZRLraqXKQw

This sounds so much more beautiful to my ears.

It's GB's favourite LIsa Kelly by the way.

I have purchased their music and listened to Celtic Women for a long time.....I agree that Susan's voice may not be as polished as theirs but as I said, considering she hasn't had years of training to smooth it all out I think she does a great job. Her voice isn't perfect but thats part of the appeal...she's not trained and polished, just natural. I listened to it with headphones and although not as smooth as Celtic Women I didn't find it to be " shrill" and I do hear purity in her voice.....but we can agree to disagree on how we hear it.

Blueskies wrote:

SusieP wrote:

Blueskies wrote:I think she sounds fantastic! Her "Le' Miz" style and sound is not unlike those of Celtic Women. She sounds like she has had vocal training and been singing professionally for years.... knowing that she hasn't...her natural gift of voice and ability is remarkable.

I just don't hear that. Sorry.

For me, the Celtic Women [I have listened to them since Gunbot raved about them] have pure voices which are not shrill when they soar to those high notes.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ZRLraqXKQw

This sounds so much more beautiful to my ears.

It's GB's favourite LIsa Kelly by the way.

I have purchased their music and listened to Celtic Women for a long time.....I agree that Susan's voice may not be as polished as theirs but as I said, considering she hasn't had years of training to smooth it all out I think she does a great job. Her voice isn't perfect but thats part of the appeal...she's not trained and polished, just natural. I listened to it with headphones and although not as smooth as Celtic Women I didn't find it to be " shrill" and I do hear purity in her voice.....but we can agree to disagree on how we hear it.

Of course we can. Just curious...........will you buy her CD BS?

SusieP wrote:

Michigan Girl wrote:I'm w/you Susie~Q....shrill!!!
She has a beautiful voice, but I can only take so
much. I found myself becoming bored w/this one...
I like my Wild Horses with a bit of an edge!!!

Wonder who chose this song for her?
I think it's an unusual choice.

Same person that chose Open Arms for Mariah, perhaps!!!
After going on that vocal rollercoaster ride, I puked!!!

Michigan Girl wrote:

SusieP wrote:

Michigan Girl wrote:I'm w/you Susie~Q....shrill!!!
She has a beautiful voice, but I can only take so
much. I found myself becoming bored w/this one...
I like my Wild Horses with a bit of an edge!!!

Wonder who chose this song for her?
I think it's an unusual choice.

Same person that chose Open Arms for Mariah, perhaps!!!
After going on that vocal rollercoaster ride, I puked!!!

Yeah but with the sales she racked up for SP and JC, I doubt they complained like our ears did!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

SusieP wrote:

Blueskies wrote:

SusieP wrote:

Blueskies wrote:I think she sounds fantastic! Her "Le' Miz" style and sound is not unlike those of Celtic Women. She sounds like she has had vocal training and been singing professionally for years.... knowing that she hasn't...her natural gift of voice and ability is remarkable.

I just don't hear that. Sorry.

For me, the Celtic Women [I have listened to them since Gunbot raved about them] have pure voices which are not shrill when they soar to those high notes.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ZRLraqXKQw

This sounds so much more beautiful to my ears.

It's GB's favourite LIsa Kelly by the way.

I have purchased their music and listened to Celtic Women for a long time.....I agree that Susan's voice may not be as polished as theirs but as I said, considering she hasn't had years of training to smooth it all out I think she does a great job. Her voice isn't perfect but thats part of the appeal...she's not trained and polished, just natural. I listened to it with headphones and although not as smooth as Celtic Women I didn't find it to be " shrill" and I do hear purity in her voice.....but we can agree to disagree on how we hear it.

Of course we can. Just curious...........will you buy her CD BS?

I don't know, like any other artist I would like to hear some more of what will be on the CD first.

Blueskies wrote:
I don't know, like any other artist I would like to hear some more of what will be on the CD first.

It should be quite interesting if the song choices are as unexpected as this one.

I must admit, I just expected Simon Cowell & Co to play it safe and just bung together a load of 'Songs from the Shows.'
I never would have guessed they would choose a Rolling Stones song!

Bloody Hell - the second single could be All Along The Watchtower or something!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

SusieP wrote:

Blueskies wrote:
I don't know, like any other artist I would like to hear some more of what will be on the CD first.

It should be quite interesting if the song choices are as unexpected as this one.

I must admit, I just expected Simon Cowell & Co to play it safe and just bing together a load of 'Songs from the Shows.'
I never would have guessed they would choose a Rolling Stones song!

Bloody Hell - the second single could be All Along The Watchtower or something!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

I am L-M-A-O!!!!

SusieP wrote:

Blueskies wrote:
I don't know, like any other artist I would like to hear some more of what will be on the CD first.

It should be quite interesting if the song choices are as unexpected as this one.

I must admit, I just expected Simon Cowell & Co to play it safe and just bung together a load of 'Songs from the Shows.'
I never would have guessed they would choose a Rolling Stones song!

Bloody Hell - the second single could be All Along The Watchtower or something!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Yes, it will be interesting to see what the other song choices were now. lol. They did pick my fave Rolling Stones song, though, and I think, although the style is different she did put emotion into the song. Heck, her voice is a lot more pure sounding then Mick Jaggers is.

Blueskies wrote:

SusieP wrote:

Blueskies wrote:
I don't know, like any other artist I would like to hear some more of what will be on the CD first.

It should be quite interesting if the song choices are as unexpected as this one.

I must admit, I just expected Simon Cowell & Co to play it safe and just bung together a load of 'Songs from the Shows.'
I never would have guessed they would choose a Rolling Stones song!

Bloody Hell - the second single could be All Along The Watchtower or something!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Yes, it will be interesting to see what the other song choices were, now. They did pick my fave Rolling Stones song, though, and I think, although the style is different she did put emotion into the song. Heck, her voice is a lot more pure sounding then Mick Jaggers is.

I cannot argue with THAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

pure is definitely not a word I would use to describe Mick Jagger's voice.


Not sure what word IS appropriate, actually.

SusieP wrote:pure is definitely not a word I would use to describe Mick Jagger's voice.


Not sure what word IS appropriate, actually.

I can't think of a good word to describe Joe Cocker's voice either, but I've always liked his music.

Blueskies wrote:

SusieP wrote:pure is definitely not a word I would use to describe Mick Jagger's voice.


Not sure what word IS appropriate, actually.

I can't think of a good word to describe Joe Cocker's voice either, but I've always liked his music.

Gravelly...edgy...

Blueskies wrote:

SusieP wrote:pure is definitely not a word I would use to describe Mick Jagger's voice.


Not sure what word IS appropriate, actually.

I can't think of a good word to describe Joe Cocker's voice either, but I've always liked his music.

I think maybe 'pickled' is the best word for him. I like his voice - but he has drunk more alcohol than the whole of his home town, I think.

SusieP wrote:

Blueskies wrote:

SusieP wrote:pure is definitely not a word I would use to describe Mick Jagger's voice.


Not sure what word IS appropriate, actually.

I can't think of a good word to describe Joe Cocker's voice either, but I've always liked his music.

I think maybe 'pickled' is the best word for him. I like his voice - but he has drunk more alcohol than the whole of his home town, I think.

Good description! Pickled works!

Blueskies wrote:

SusieP wrote:

Blueskies wrote:

SusieP wrote:pure is definitely not a word I would use to describe Mick Jagger's voice.


Not sure what word IS appropriate, actually.

I can't think of a good word to describe Joe Cocker's voice either, but I've always liked his music.

I think maybe 'pickled' is the best word for him. I like his voice - but he has drunk more alcohol than the whole of his home town, I think.

Good discription! Pickled works!

Us silly Brits have our uses.

Interesting choice of song, but the arrangement works with her vocal style very well. I'm impressed.
I'd say she's a little strained on the top notes in a few places, rather than shrill, but I can live with it.

I found this version by Susan very boring. Couldn't listen to it all. Not a good song choice at all. While she might have a good voice she needs to not do the Stones.

Good song, beautiful voice. Nice to see that those behind the desk haven't produced the shit out of her, leaving a robot vocal in place. best thing about this vocal is the fact you can hear the emotion and the strain....great stuff.

Andrew wrote:Good song, beautiful voice. Nice to see that those behind the desk haven't produced the shit out of her, leaving a robot vocal in place. best thing about this vocal is the fact you can hear the emotion and the strain....great stuff.

Exactly! I was afraid they would overproduce her too and take away her own unique qualities. I'm glad that they just let her be natural and sing from the heart.

Andrew wrote:Good song, beautiful voice. Nice to see that those behind the desk haven't produced the shit out of her, leaving a robot vocal in place. best thing about this vocal is the fact you can hear the emotion and the strain....great stuff.

On the higher notes I can hear some strong compression and perhaps a bit of vocal processing to give it more youthful sound. But she sounds awesome. wow..

Blueskies wrote:I think she sounds fantastic! Her "Le' Miz" style and sound is not unlike those of Celtic Women. She sounds like she has had vocal training and been singing professionally for years.... knowing that she hasn't...her natural gift of voice and ability is remarkable.

I agree with you Blueskies what a beautiful voice she has.I will be getting her cd when it comes out.

Love Susan Boyle! This is what it's all about right here, def brings a smile to my face.

Andrew wrote:Good song, beautiful voice. Nice to see that those behind the desk haven't produced the shit out of her, leaving a robot vocal in place. best thing about this vocal is the fact you can hear the emotion and the strain....great stuff.

+1

SB sooo reminds me of Julie Andrews..... that purity of tone is pretty amazing..

I liked it! I think picking a song so totally unexpected and doing a completely different arrangement was brilliant. Loved the piano as well. Yes, it does sound a little Broadway, but that's her style isn't it? I do agree the song dragged a bit, would like to hear her sing something more up tempo.

I liked it, too. I'll probably buy her CD...hope it's a good mix of upbeat and reflective songs.