MR

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mE4JQFwfoxQ

never heard of this guy but kinda like his range.

I like this version


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=idE1lsqG2Vc

portland wrote:I like this version


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=idE1lsqG2Vc

well sure, the great one is singing. But lately all I find is arnie boys rejected crappy sing-a-long disney style bullshit.

ScarabGator wrote:

portland wrote:I like this version


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=idE1lsqG2Vc

well sure, the great one is singing. But lately all I find is arnie boys rejected crappy sing-a-long disney style bullshit.

You can't mess with perfection.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EQ1X-ym8vFQ

Prove me wrong, ya can't!

Since 78 wrote:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EQ1X-ym8vFQ

Prove me wrong, ya can't!

its so so. Jeremey nails this song better.

ScarabGator wrote:

Since 78 wrote:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EQ1X-ym8vFQ

Prove me wrong, ya can't!

its so so. Jeremey nails this song better.

I think its great just pulling it off cold like that, and no offense to Jeremey, but I disagree.

Since 78 wrote:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EQ1X-ym8vFQ

Prove me wrong, ya can't!

Funny Guy 78.....but for me it ruins the song....ya can't mess with perfection.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nR4vi0q19lc

portland wrote:

Since 78 wrote:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EQ1X-ym8vFQ

Prove me wrong, ya can't!

Funny Guy 78.....but for me it ruins the song....ya can't mess with perfection.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nR4vi0q19lc

Its perfect cause its not live. That was my point.

This guy can sing and reminds me of some popular Christian artists.

I will repeat something I have said before... for some reason this song immediately struck me as one that Brooks and Dunn should have recorded and made a mint with.

portland wrote:I like this version


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=idE1lsqG2Vc

Well now you went and did it to me. I am in a puddle now That boy had it going on Did i tell you i loved his hair?

portland wrote:

ScarabGator wrote:

portland wrote:I like this version


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=idE1lsqG2Vc

well sure, the great one is singing. But lately all I find is arnie boys rejected crappy sing-a-long disney style bullshit.

You can't mess with perfection.

Since 78 wrote:

portland wrote:

Since 78 wrote:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EQ1X-ym8vFQ

Prove me wrong, ya can't!

Funny Guy 78.....but for me it ruins the song....ya can't mess with perfection.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nR4vi0q19lc

Its perfect cause its not live. That was my point.

So we've got it on record that we can listen to over and over. SP's rendition of these 2 songs are perfection....no one can touch the depth or feeling, live or otherwise.

ScarabGator wrote:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mE4JQFwfoxQ

never heard of this guy but kinda like his range.

Bullocks!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2WSpaS1pqEY

steveo777 wrote:

ScarabGator wrote:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mE4JQFwfoxQ

never heard of this guy but kinda like his range.

Bullocks!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2WSpaS1pqEY

Okay, grudgingly ...I have to give Arnel props here. He sang this very well. And he always does OA well. Faithfully, however, I've never thought he did well in any of the yt videos I've seen.

annie89509 wrote:

Since 78 wrote:Its perfect cause its not live. That was my point.

So we've got it on record that we can listen to over and over. SP's rendition of these 2 songs are perfection....no one can touch the depth or feeling, live or otherwise.

I'm w/Annie here
I'm a WYLAW connoisseur!! Who gives a diddely~do if the man that originated that songs never sings it live ...he did it GOOD!!
I would be will be happy, though, if I did feel that reach right in your chest and jerk your heart out
beating and bleeding in the palm of his hand depth and emotion from anyone else!! Hasn't happened yet ...
This song can never be touched ...well none of them can, but definitely not this one!!

These comparisons ...waste of time!!

Brooks and Dunn ...I am LMAO!!!

Are you in the woods Tatar drinkin miller lite?? i sure hope so

How come nobody ever comes around with a youtube for TDTWT. Why does everybody try to hitch Arnel's cart to the older songs that already had their day on the charts with that other guy? If loons are living in the past, then the pinheads are right behind them. Where's all the love for AATY? Just keep comparing him to the guy that made the songs famous and you'll never dump that cover singer title for Pineda. After the new album comes out I give it two months before the youtubes of DSB and Faithfully out number the videos of the new songs from their upcoming album. Living in the past, yeah, aren't we all? News flash for you. No matter how well Arnel sings those songs, they will always belong to the guys who made them famous 25 years ago. No matter how much of a good guy, or humble person Arnel is, unless his fans get behind one of these new songs and start promoting those instead of the dirty dozen or the latest Bryan Adams cover the guy is doing, the guy will be remembered for nothing ten years from now. I mean, are these fans just so embarrased by the quality of newer material that they would rather opt to promote videos of Open Arms vs Where Did I lose Your Love? Keep it up and Pineda's legacy is simply going to be the guy who replaced the guy who stepped in for Augeri.
Siily pinheads.

Don wrote:How come nobody ever comes around with a youtube for TDTWT. Why does everybody try to hitch Arnel's cart to the older songs that already had their day on the charts with that other guy? If loons are living in the past, then the pinheads are right behind them. Where's all the love for AATY? Just keep comparing him to the guy that made the songs famous and you'll never dump that cover singer title for Pineda. After the new album comes out I give it two months before the youtubes of DSB and Faithfully out number the videos of the new songs from their upcoming album. Living in the past, yeah, aren't we all? News flash for you. No matter how well Arnel sings those songs, they will always belong to the guys who made them famous 25 years ago. No matter how much of a good guy, or humble person Arnel is, unless his fans get behind one of these new songs and start promoting those instead of the dirty dozen or the latest Bryan Adams cover the guy is doing, the guy will be remembered for nothing ten years from now. I mean, are these fans just so embarrased by the quality of newer material that they would rather opt to promote videos of Open Arms vs Where Did I lose Your Love? Keep it up and Pineda's legacy is simply going to be the guy who replaced the guy who stepped in for Augeri.
Siily pinheads.

Love, Love~~

I think he is lipping,perfect fit for Journey, Neals is getting wood now, just for a backup for when the Walmart money runs out ,and it will

ScarabGator wrote:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mE4JQFwfoxQ

never heard of this guy but kinda like his range.

Sounds like Jimi Jamison.

annie89509 wrote:

steveo777 wrote:

ScarabGator wrote:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mE4JQFwfoxQ

never heard of this guy but kinda like his range.

Bullocks!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2WSpaS1pqEY

Okay, grudgingly ...I have to give Arnel props here. He sang this very well. And he always does OA well. Faithfully, however, I've never thought he did well in any of the yt videos I've seen.

Agreed Annie, Arnel didn't too bad on that actually. But this dude comes closer to Perry's soulful delivery than anyone IMO........wish they would have put the whole song up.....he nails it! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Gn8TzSoF1M

Deb wrote:

annie89509 wrote:

steveo777 wrote:

ScarabGator wrote:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mE4JQFwfoxQ

never heard of this guy but kinda like his range.

Bullocks!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2WSpaS1pqEY

Okay, grudgingly ...I have to give Arnel props here. He sang this very well. And he always does OA well. Faithfully, however, I've never thought he did well in any of the yt videos I've seen.

Agreed Annie, Arnel didn't too bad on that actually. But this dude comes closer to Perry's soulful delivery than anyone IMO........wish they would have put the whole song up.....he nails it! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Gn8TzSoF1M

Obviously, Perry is best.....but, for fuck's sakes, anybody on that song but JSS. Hell, I think even Cain could sing it better.
Not an impressive performance! JSS is a good singer, but there's a damn good reason he's not singing Journey songs, no matter how jaded the opinion of JSS coming from a fan.

steveo777 wrote:

Deb wrote:

annie89509 wrote:

steveo777 wrote:

ScarabGator wrote:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mE4JQFwfoxQ

never heard of this guy but kinda like his range.

Bullocks!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2WSpaS1pqEY

Okay, grudgingly ...I have to give Arnel props here. He sang this very well. And he always does OA well. Faithfully, however, I've never thought he did well in any of the yt videos I've seen.

Agreed Annie, Arnel didn't too bad on that actually. But this dude comes closer to Perry's soulful delivery than anyone IMO........wish they would have put the whole song up.....he nails it! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Gn8TzSoF1M

Obviously, Perry is best.....but, for fuck's sakes, anybody on that song but JSS. Hell, I think even Cain could sing it better.

Are you serious??? Tone and delivery, he sounds more like Perry on that than any other clip I've heard.

steveo777 wrote:

Deb wrote:

annie89509 wrote:

steveo777 wrote:

ScarabGator wrote:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mE4JQFwfoxQ

never heard of this guy but kinda like his range.

Bullocks!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2WSpaS1pqEY

Okay, grudgingly ...I have to give Arnel props here. He sang this very well. And he always does OA well. Faithfully, however, I've never thought he did well in any of the yt videos I've seen.

Agreed Annie, Arnel didn't too bad on that actually. But this dude comes closer to Perry's soulful delivery than anyone IMO........wish they would have put the whole song up.....he nails it! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Gn8TzSoF1M

Obviously, Perry is best.....but, for fuck's sakes, anybody on that song but JSS. Hell, I think even Cain could sing it better.
Not an impressive performance! JSS is a good singer, but there's a damn good reason he's not singing Journey songs, no matter how jaded the opinion of JSS coming from a fan.

You're so full of Pooh ...do you even know what soul and emotion are?!?! I think not!!
Deb~I'd love to hear that in full, without audience interference ...I think I might love it!!
Also, I think Arnel does a great job on many of the DD, but he absolutely ruins WYLAW for me ...sorry!!

I vote this as one of the worst threads of the year, and let me tell you why. This thread contains the finest examples of the worst type of posters bar far.

1) SG, I like you Tim, you know that, and I get you dislike Pineda, but there's plenty of ways to say it other than "Arnie Boy sucks." The guy is very green behind the ears, and is frankly not a good front man, but he can sing.

2) Of course Portland has to come with predictable Perry is perfect bullshit. That got old 4 years ago, and frankly, in this very case, I give the nod to Pineda, for he actually sang it live, whereas Espee didn't. Newsflash, Perry wasn't perfect and he did flub up at times too.

3) Since '78. I like this guy. Yeah, a big self embarrassing Pinhead fan, but I guess there are worse things in life to be called. 78 makes good points, but in this thread, the Pinhead nation fulfilled it's reputation as the most annoying on MR, however, the Perry Loons are no better. Like I said '78, you are good poster, buy the Pinhead nation is just some dorky shit IMHO.

Relax Timbo, I get your point. You think Pineda isn't nearly as good as the MR press would have you believe, and I agree. I think Andrew polished his knob way too early throughout the beginning of his career. I will say his myopic fans are much to blame and a huge embarrassment when they compare Pineda to Perry.

You just added to the stench in this thread ...we aren't talking about perfection as humans!!
And Pineda will never touch Perry on this song live, dead, or in your head!!! Sorry!!:evil:

Rhyme ^^^^

Michigan Girl wrote:You just added to the stinch in this thread ...we aren't talking about perfection as humans!!
And Pineda will never touch Perry on this song live, dead, or in your head!!! Sorry!!:evil:

Rhyme ^^^^

Whatever, C. So you don't like me. I don't care.

I am pointing out that Tim can give a better way of explaining why Pineda is not the greatest singer ever; why Perry isn't perfect...this one is getting ridiculous as of late. and why Pinhead nation is s bad as the Loons. Yet I add the stinch? Ok, whatever.

Perry never sang the song live, so how do we know he could pull it off like the recorded version?

steveo777 wrote:

Deb wrote:

annie89509 wrote:

steveo777 wrote:

ScarabGator wrote:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mE4JQFwfoxQ

never heard of this guy but kinda like his range.

Bullocks!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2WSpaS1pqEY

Okay, grudgingly ...I have to give Arnel props here. He sang this very well. And he always does OA well. Faithfully, however, I've never thought he did well in any of the yt videos I've seen.

Agreed Annie, Arnel didn't too bad on that actually. But this dude comes closer to Perry's soulful delivery than anyone IMO........wish they would have put the whole song up.....he nails it! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Gn8TzSoF1M

Obviously, Perry is best.....but, for fuck's sakes, anybody on that song but JSS. Hell, I think even Cain could sing it better.
Not an impressive performance! JSS is a good singer, but there's a damn good reason he's not singing Journey songs, no matter how jaded the opinion of JSS coming from a fan.

Cain ??? that isnt his real name, and the poor bitch cant sing a lick, fat ass

Rockindeano wrote:

Michigan Girl wrote:You just added to the stench in this thread ...we aren't talking about perfection as humans!!
And Pineda will never touch Perry on this song live, dead, or in your head!!! Sorry!!:evil:

Rhyme ^^^^

Whatever, C. So you don't like me. I don't care.

I m pointing out that Tim can give a better way of explaining why Pineda is not the greatest singer ever; why Perry isn't perfect...this one is getting ridiculous as of late. and why Pinhead nation is s bad as the Loons. Yet I add the stinch? Ok, whatever.

I love you and it's stEnch!!
Really, everything you said was very true ...I was referring to the props to AP for singing it live, but that is your opinion
I'm just disagreeing w/it!! WTH!!:wink:

Well we dont ^^^^^to your edit!! But we've never heard Pineda;s recorded version either ...can he do it AS good?!?!

The emooootion ....ooooooh yeah!!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=idE1lsqG ... re=related