verslibre wrote:He's referring to superheroes, man. If you need to get that technical, you can go back to OG Star Trek. You can go back to The Twilight Zone. And you can keep going back...
Well, he didn't say that, did he? And, it's not that "technical'.
I also do not recall two actors ever playing the same role on either Star Trek (any version) or Twilight Zone. I also do not know what OG:Star Trek is. Do you mean ST:TOS? That's how I know it, anyway: ST:TOS, ST:TNG, ST:V, ST:DS9, ST:E, ST:D....I don't know how Piccard is referred to, I spose ST:P...and I don't know about any other of CBS:All Access series.
What are we discussing, DC's current plans, or everything filmed within the last hundred years?
Well, YJ said that DC was the first to have two actors playing the same role appear in a scene together. I pointed out that is simply NOT TRUE...and you are trying to argue with me about that FACT.
Monker wrote:verslibre wrote:I guess for you that would only make a difference had TV shows and films featuring multiple DC characters began appearing in 1940. It took decades for comic book properties to be considered viable, and DC still gatecrashed the boob tube and the silver screen with Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman and crushed that hurdle flat. It took a long time for monies to be invested to make these grandiose stories be adapted and waved through with the same conveniences afforded traditional SFF.
I really don't care about any of that. The only thing I'll say to that is most comic book movies are NOT science fiction...they are fantasy.
Again, what exactly are YOU discussing? I think you're having a conversation with yourself.
Well, I was definitely not discussing the entire history of DC comics and TV. I just don't care. But, there is a specific definition of what Science Fiction is, and most comic book stories do not fall into that genre. They are more fantasy. Actually, they are more modern day myths more akin to Greek and Roman myth. Did you know that "superheroes" are essentially unique to the US? What "superhero" did England invent, or Spain, or Germany? They have become American Mythology.
But whatever, most of it is NOT science fiction.
And all that third-rate "science fiction" you love isn't really SF, it's SFF, or science fantasy – emphasis on FANTASY. Doctor Whooters, too!
Dr. Who is absolutely science fiction. It's about a species of people who can travel through time and space, and one that went rogue. If you remove that you can not tell the story.
Star Whores is space opera, which is an unabashed fantasy in an interstellar setting.
Correct. There is no "science" thread used to tell the story. It could easily be told in a completely different setting.
That's the only fucking difference. What do you think a lightsaber represents? A sword.
Correct. It's a laser sword. That is what Lucas originally called it...and why Luke calls it a "laser sword" in "The Last Jedi".