
Moderator: Andrew
4everkop wrote:Is it me or does he get too much credit for singing, people wanted him to front journey, but even that'd be too stupid for them to hire him, he just looks like perry, and has a weaker voice. Why does he get so much credit?
finalfight wrote:4everkop wrote:Is it me or does he get too much credit for singing, people wanted him to front journey, but even that'd be too stupid for them to hire him, he just looks like perry, and has a weaker voice. Why does he get so much credit?
Because he's a bloody good solo artist in his own right.
Journey69 wrote:Hugo is good.. But if he toured with Journey for even 6 months,his voice would be shot.. Not sure Jeremey could handle it either.. SP,Arnel and JSS all have very strong voices.. Anyone that sounds like Perry,even doing their own stuff is going to get compared..I really think that sucks.. Because people expect the guy to be Perry.. IMO
STORY_TELLER wrote:Hugo gets credit because he's the one guy out there who knows how to write original lyrics and melodies with Perry's emotional content in a VERY Journey like way.
I'm a big Hugo fan on his originals. At one point I thought he should be lead in Journey because, between Neal, Jon and Hugo, writing and melody wise, I really thought they would create new music which sounded and felt like frontiers era Journey. That being said, after seeing clips of him singing live, I wouldn't want him in the band.
Hugo really does wonders in the studio, but not so much playing live. He used to belt, but as he went more and more into imitating Perry, he's taken to singing through his middle voice and vocally he became weak. Sounds fine in a studio where he can tweak the songs to perfection, but now and forever, Journey is a live touring band. I don't think he could cut it out there.
Hunsiker has a stronger voice overall, but Hugo's stronger when it comes to originating music.
ScarabGator wrote:I really do like Hugo's solo stuff. But his Perry imitation pales in comparison to Jeremey.
fanofjourney1 wrote:STORY_TELLER wrote:Hugo gets credit because he's the one guy out there who knows how to write original lyrics and melodies with Perry's emotional content in a VERY Journey like way.
I'm a big Hugo fan on his originals. At one point I thought he should be lead in Journey because, between Neal, Jon and Hugo, writing and melody wise, I really thought they would create new music which sounded and felt like frontiers era Journey. That being said, after seeing clips of him singing live, I wouldn't want him in the band.
Hugo really does wonders in the studio, but not so much playing live. He used to belt, but as he went more and more into imitating Perry, he's taken to singing through his middle voice and vocally he became weak. Sounds fine in a studio where he can tweak the songs to perfection, but now and forever, Journey is a live touring band. I don't think he could cut it out there.
Hunsiker has a stronger voice overall, but Hugo's stronger when it comes to originating music.
I have to disagree with you, have you seen Hugo live?
Let me tell you, he does belts them out and really draws you in especially with the ballads. His band Evolution is playing Dec 22nd in Manhattan, very excited to see him again.
STORY_TELLER wrote:fanofjourney1 wrote:STORY_TELLER wrote:Hugo gets credit because he's the one guy out there who knows how to write original lyrics and melodies with Perry's emotional content in a VERY Journey like way.
I'm a big Hugo fan on his originals. At one point I thought he should be lead in Journey because, between Neal, Jon and Hugo, writing and melody wise, I really thought they would create new music which sounded and felt like frontiers era Journey. That being said, after seeing clips of him singing live, I wouldn't want him in the band.
Hugo really does wonders in the studio, but not so much playing live. He used to belt, but as he went more and more into imitating Perry, he's taken to singing through his middle voice and vocally he became weak. Sounds fine in a studio where he can tweak the songs to perfection, but now and forever, Journey is a live touring band. I don't think he could cut it out there.
Hunsiker has a stronger voice overall, but Hugo's stronger when it comes to originating music.
I have to disagree with you, have you seen Hugo live?
Let me tell you, he does belts them out and really draws you in especially with the ballads. His band Evolution is playing Dec 22nd in Manhattan, very excited to see him again.
I haven't seen him live, no. But I've seen the you tube clips of him live performing both Journey and his own solo material. He has a tendency to be pitchy live. I've read interviews with him where he himself has stated that producer's he's worked with have always pushed him to project his voice more and he didn't want to.
I'm saying this as a Hugo fan. I have all his solo stuff and I play it regularly on my iPod. He's great in the studio and has proven himself to be an artist and not just a karaoke singer. He needs to shelve the tribute band stuff completely. It's only hurt him.
STORY_TELLER wrote:fanofjourney1 wrote:STORY_TELLER wrote:Hugo gets credit because he's the one guy out there who knows how to write original lyrics and melodies with Perry's emotional content in a VERY Journey like way.
I'm a big Hugo fan on his originals. At one point I thought he should be lead in Journey because, between Neal, Jon and Hugo, writing and melody wise, I really thought they would create new music which sounded and felt like frontiers era Journey. That being said, after seeing clips of him singing live, I wouldn't want him in the band.
Hugo really does wonders in the studio, but not so much playing live. He used to belt, but as he went more and more into imitating Perry, he's taken to singing through his middle voice and vocally he became weak. Sounds fine in a studio where he can tweak the songs to perfection, but now and forever, Journey is a live touring band. I don't think he could cut it out there.
Hunsiker has a stronger voice overall, but Hugo's stronger when it comes to originating music.
I have to disagree with you, have you seen Hugo live?
Let me tell you, he does belts them out and really draws you in especially with the ballads. His band Evolution is playing Dec 22nd in Manhattan, very excited to see him again.
I haven't seen him live, no. But I've seen the you tube clips of him live performing both Journey and his own solo material. He has a tendency to be pitchy live. I've read interviews with him where he himself has stated that producer's he's worked with have always pushed him to project his voice more and he didn't want to.
I'm saying this as a Hugo fan. I have all his solo stuff and I play it regularly on my iPod. He's great in the studio and has proven himself to be an artist and not just a karaoke singer. He needs to shelve the tribute band stuff completely. It's only hurt him.
finalfight wrote:STORY_TELLER wrote:fanofjourney1 wrote:STORY_TELLER wrote:Hugo gets credit because he's the one guy out there who knows how to write original lyrics and melodies with Perry's emotional content in a VERY Journey like way.
I'm a big Hugo fan on his originals. At one point I thought he should be lead in Journey because, between Neal, Jon and Hugo, writing and melody wise, I really thought they would create new music which sounded and felt like frontiers era Journey. That being said, after seeing clips of him singing live, I wouldn't want him in the band.
Hugo really does wonders in the studio, but not so much playing live. He used to belt, but as he went more and more into imitating Perry, he's taken to singing through his middle voice and vocally he became weak. Sounds fine in a studio where he can tweak the songs to perfection, but now and forever, Journey is a live touring band. I don't think he could cut it out there.
Hunsiker has a stronger voice overall, but Hugo's stronger when it comes to originating music.
I have to disagree with you, have you seen Hugo live?
Let me tell you, he does belts them out and really draws you in especially with the ballads. His band Evolution is playing Dec 22nd in Manhattan, very excited to see him again.
I haven't seen him live, no. But I've seen the you tube clips of him live performing both Journey and his own solo material. He has a tendency to be pitchy live. I've read interviews with him where he himself has stated that producer's he's worked with have always pushed him to project his voice more and he didn't want to.
I'm saying this as a Hugo fan. I have all his solo stuff and I play it regularly on my iPod. He's great in the studio and has proven himself to be an artist and not just a karaoke singer. He needs to shelve the tribute band stuff completely. It's only hurt him.
He was incredible live at Firefest his voice was really, really powerful and not at all like the horrible soft Evolution pro-shot videos. There are some good clips on YouTube.
finalfight wrote:STORY_TELLER wrote:fanofjourney1 wrote:STORY_TELLER wrote:Hugo gets credit because he's the one guy out there who knows how to write original lyrics and melodies with Perry's emotional content in a VERY Journey like way.
I'm a big Hugo fan on his originals. At one point I thought he should be lead in Journey because, between Neal, Jon and Hugo, writing and melody wise, I really thought they would create new music which sounded and felt like frontiers era Journey. That being said, after seeing clips of him singing live, I wouldn't want him in the band.
Hugo really does wonders in the studio, but not so much playing live. He used to belt, but as he went more and more into imitating Perry, he's taken to singing through his middle voice and vocally he became weak. Sounds fine in a studio where he can tweak the songs to perfection, but now and forever, Journey is a live touring band. I don't think he could cut it out there.
Hunsiker has a stronger voice overall, but Hugo's stronger when it comes to originating music.
I have to disagree with you, have you seen Hugo live?
Let me tell you, he does belts them out and really draws you in especially with the ballads. His band Evolution is playing Dec 22nd in Manhattan, very excited to see him again.
I haven't seen him live, no. But I've seen the you tube clips of him live performing both Journey and his own solo material. He has a tendency to be pitchy live. I've read interviews with him where he himself has stated that producer's he's worked with have always pushed him to project his voice more and he didn't want to.
I'm saying this as a Hugo fan. I have all his solo stuff and I play it regularly on my iPod. He's great in the studio and has proven himself to be an artist and not just a karaoke singer. He needs to shelve the tribute band stuff completely. It's only hurt him.
He was incredible live at Firefest his voice was really, really powerful and not at all like the horrible soft Evolution pro-shot videos. There are some good clips on YouTube.
4everkop wrote:Is it me or does he get too much credit for singing, people wanted him to front journey, but even that'd be too stupid for them to hire him, he just looks like perry, and has a weaker voice. Why does he get so much credit?
That is an interesting thought. I became a fan of Hugo BECAUSE of his Journey Tribute baggage, but I LOVE his solo stuff. He has an absolutely awesome voice, IMO because it has the Steve Perry emotional delivery influence.Maro wrote:Hugo is one of the best aor voices in business... but - he'd be taken more seriously without this tribute to Journey baggage...
At the time of Trial By Fire his first solo album got better reviews... I wonder how would his Ramos/Hugo and Valentine II projects do in comparison to new Journey album with Arnel...
journeyrock wrote:That is an interesting thought. I became a fan of Hugo BECAUSE of his Journey Tribute baggage, but I LOVE his solo stuff. He has an absolutely awesome voice, IMO because it has the Steve Perry emotional delivery influence.
journeyrock wrote:I have to agree with you. I was disappointed on Steve Perry's solo tour when he sang Journey songs without Neal on guitar. Even though Lincoln did a very good job, it wasn't the same. And it's the same concept as someone trying to copy Steve Perry's voice. Can't be done.
Sorry, I can't get this quote thing figured out here, but you get the picture.
Yes, I understand your thinking.Maro wrote:journeyrock wrote:I have to agree with you. I was disappointed on Steve Perry's solo tour when he sang Journey songs without Neal on guitar. Even though Lincoln did a very good job, it wasn't the same. And it's the same concept as someone trying to copy Steve Perry's voice. Can't be done.
Sorry, I can't get this quote thing figured out here, but you get the picture.
I understand how you feel, and there are many people thinking very simmilar... however, I am a bit more liberal in vocal department, but I simply can't digest butchering of Journey guitar&keyboard sound... That's why I don't like Kevin Chalfant's Fly 2 Fr33dom album... And it comes from Kevin's big fan (I simply adore his two The Storm albums, and have found many good songs on his other albums)... I could live with Kevin doing something he could/should have done much better 12-13 years ago in different circumstances (CHALFANT-SCHON-VALORY-ROLIE-CAIN-SMITH) , but his instrumental backing on Fly 2 Fr33dom completely destroyed the picture... I don't know if Josh Ramos on guitar and Gregg Rolie on keys could have saved the thing, but Fly 2 Fr33dom was miles away from what I expected, and I don't mean it in good way...
texafana wrote:Looks a bit like SteveP, doesn't have near enough vocal pizazz in his Journey covers. JH is superior in every way.
Jeremey wrote:Journey69 wrote:Hugo is good.. But if he toured with Journey for even 6 months,his voice would be shot.. Not sure Jeremey could handle it either.. SP,Arnel and JSS all have very strong voices.. Anyone that sounds like Perry,even doing their own stuff is going to get compared..I really think that sucks.. Because people expect the guy to be Perry.. IMO
80 minute sets 4 days a week with hundreds of thousands of dollars of monitor and PA? Piece of cake.
Maro wrote:Hugo is one of the best aor voices in business... but - he'd be taken more seriously without this tribute to Journey baggage...
At the time of Trial By Fire his first solo album got better reviews... I wonder how would his Ramos/Hugo and Valentine II projects do in comparison to new Journey album with Arnel...
I have to agree with you. I was disappointed on Steve Perry's solo tour when he sang Journey songs without Neal on guitar. Even though Lincoln did a very good job, it wasn't the same. And it's the same concept as someone trying to copy Steve Perry's voice. Can't be done.
finalfight wrote:STORY_TELLER wrote:fanofjourney1 wrote:STORY_TELLER wrote:
He was incredible live at Firefest his voice was really, really powerful and not at all like the horrible soft Evolution pro-shot videos. There are some good clips on YouTube.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 39 guests