danielb wrote:It would have been interesting to hear JSS do a full album with them. If Soul Sirkus was anything to go by, it could have been a belter.
Not to mention, JSS brought showmanship in spades and a rock vibe to the show which has been missing ever since.
I think this has been way over estimated by JSS fans. In the DL/Journey show I saw, DL was CLEARLY the headliner and completely blew Journey off the stage. The entire production of the show was better. They presented the music better. They showcased the band better. DL was clearly the better band. Journey came across as a struggling band, trying their best but still not quite good enough to claim a headliner spot. JSS was NOT this shot in the arm answer to all of Journey's problems.
Neal recently hinted at personality clashes and it's likely JSS would have been too much his own man in order for it to last in the long run.
Neal says a lot of things, some of which I clearly do not believe any longer. Neal had months, or even years, experience working with JSS prior to him joining Journey. If there were personality conflicts, he would have known about them before he even joined the band.
Instead, they got Arnel and went down a more karaoke inspired path. Good move for the wallet, not so much for the creative side.
Journey has a history of doing this...dating back to the ROR days. They clearly had a path to move on without Perry. Instead they gave him everything he wanted to get back into the band for ROR...pushing Herbie to the side, allowing him to produce the album, decide on the artwork, fire members, hiring members, dictating the musical direction. Then they repeated it in the early 90's, despite Herbie's warning. They could have moved on with Chalfant and Gregg. Instead, at Sony's encouragement, they traded Chalfant, Rolie, and Herbie to get Steve Perry on board...and a reunion contract from Sony ($). So, it does not surprise me at all that they gave Wal-Mart what they wanted with a Perry sound-a-like and a rerecorded GH album as part of the Revolution package...even though Neal had been saying he wanted the EXACT OPPOSITE for years prior.