StocktontoMalone wrote:brywool wrote:G.I.Jim wrote:Gibby wrote:That was a tight off the cuff delivery of Lights into shitty radio station mics. Arnel has got an amazing fucking voice and the background vox were right on.
Amen. I don't hear what you guys are hearing that didn't like it (and I'm very critical of them lately!). They kicked ass in this clip. JMHO.

well, it's Arnel and not Perry, Jss, Augeri, Eric Martin, or Jeremey. It HAS to suck, right?

You know, I'm gonna chime in. And you're not gonna like it.
If a couple of tracks were released off revelation - but it wasn't Journey, but some new melodic group -
everyone would be stoked. Even me. But knowing that it is Journey, where you have a a great schism among the fans - you don't get that. You get division. Plus the fact that the whole package really isn't up to prior(very prior, in fact) standards - you get more division, and negative feedback.
A good percentage of the hype is from Pinoy nation, and rightfully so. And the remainder is mostly from people who travel to see the band, and love the fact that they have continued opportunities to get together, drink, and run amok. And for the latter, it doesn't make a damn difference who is fronting the band.
Not sure what you're saying here, so it doesn't really bug me (I'm pretty thick). Personally, I think Revelation stands up against Generations and certainly TBF. I think it's better than both of those albums actually. But yeah, there are just these 'factions' that never stop with comparing it to this or that or u constantly hear "Well, so and so could've done it better". Maybe that's true, but you know, so and so didn't get the gig, so it really isn't worth talking about. It'd be nice if people took it for what it is, which is a pretty solid album. The re-records are one thing- I think Arnel did a great job with them but the production really was pretty ragged.
Obviously, peeps can think what they want and post what they want, but I can see why peeps have burned out on MR because almost every post degenerates into a singer comparison. Kind of like in the Styx forum everything turns into a DeYoung protest (one way or the other). As for the Pinoy nation, I've read people slagging the guy or the band JUST because his country's proud of Arnel, which I don't get. I'd think that fans of Journey would be happy about all the press. So what if it's Arnel that's getting the focus? He's REALLY the only STORY in Journey that's interesting or isn't covered with some kind of wart. I mean, I think it'd be tough to make Neal the focus because he seems so abrasive, Cain because he's really not interesting, Ross-- um, yeah... I dunno. Arnel's story is pretty newsworthy and from what I can tell (Like Augeri) he's GREAT with the fans and deserves some kudos.
Yeah, yeah, I know... I keep beating the Arnel drum, which surprises me as much as anyone, I just don't get the constant dislike of the guy who's really keeping this band alive.