Gin and Tonic Sky wrote:conversationpc wrote:Memorex wrote:Predictions on the outcome of the Obamacare Supreme Court case????
I think the court will probably go ahead and decide on it (I hope anyway so that time is not wasted). I also believe they will not strike down the law. I hate the mandate and I personally think the constitution does not give Congress the right to force someone to buy something such as health care. That said, I think one or two of the conservative judges will act in accordance with believing the court should not intervene when Congress has passed a law. So I think it will be 5-4 or 6-3 in favor of allowing the law.
I think it could go either way...At this point, however, I'm guessing they will decide in favor of the Obama Administration.
I agree. Its actually up to Scalia and Kennedy. I think one is going to side with Obama. and that will be 5-4.
but anyone who tells you for certain how these guys will vote is lying. There is alot of uncharted territory here.
A lot changed since I posted that and it looks like it may now go the other way. I actually posted on Facebook after the Obama administration's fiasco in court yesterday that it almost looked like they were purposely throwing the case so they could use it as a wedge issue and then tie it to something like the 2000 election, which went to the Supreme Court. Now look at this article from The Blaze...
Are the Democrats expecting to lose the battle over healthcare? Judging from the comments made by several prominent Dems, the party is prepping for what to do after the high court shoots down the individual mandate.
Two days ago, former DNC Chair Howard Dean told CBS Early Morning that he expected the individual mandate to be overturned.
Yesterday, CNN’s Legal Analyst Jeffry Toobin called the proceedings “a train wreck” and predicted that the individual mandate will “likely be struck down.” If true, how will the Democrats then spin the defeat to their benefit? Enter James Carville.
Last night on CNN, the Democratic consultant made a curious statement about what happens if the Supreme Court rules against the administration. He appears to already be ratcheting up the anti-Republican and anti-Supreme Court rhetoric in preparation, even tying a possible Obamacare defeat to the Bush-Gore election of 2000.
Consider Mr. Carville’s words regarding a potential defeat in the Supreme Court (after saying a defeat would be the “best thing” for Democrats because of rising health care costs):
“They overturned an election. And just as a professional Democrat, there’s nothing better for me than they overturn this thing 5-4. And then the Republican Party will own this health care system for the foreseeable future. … Go see Scalia when you want health care.”
In other words: the Supreme Court gave the country Bush, and now it’s going to take away your health care.
“This is not spin,” he reassured.
Really?
http://www.theblaze.com/stories/did-jam ... verturned/









