JR (Susie) wrote:I don't have a clue about the $$$ of any deals. That's not my business.
But it is your business to make a song and dance about what some unnnamed record executive from London said about wanting to sign them? All this "I respect their privacy" chat is just a cop-out and you know it.
I've NEVER claimed to have an inside track on this saga. Not once.
You are one of the worst offenders when it comes to making out you have inside information. Anyway, I'm glad you're FINALLY addmitting you don't have a clue.
How do u know he would have had to shell out a few hundred thou? U don't. In fact for all intents & purposes, they had a record deal. Therefore he would not have had to shell out anything. Yes, he lost money on SS, he says. But that was his baby.
Well, Andrew also said the best option for Journey was to do what REO Speedwagon did which was self-finance the recording and packaging of the album and do a deal with Wal-Mart to sell it. In other words...that the band themselves had to lay down the initial investment. My point is that after the sting of losing £300,000 maybe Schon felt unhappy with the idea of just signing a distribution deal for the new Journey record and picking up the tab for the rest?
You can keep saying that the economics don't matter and that they are none of your business or whatever. But my guess is that JSS was let go primarily because Schon and Cain felt it wasn't lucrative enough to record new music with him. That it would in fact end up costing THEM money.
I was expecting new music. I didn't expect them to get signed w/a label tho.
So who was meant to pay for the new record then?
I didn't want to lose what I had come to love about Jeff.
Susie - we've exchanged many PMs and there is all kinds of information which I wouldn't reveal on this board. I didn't think that your thoughts on JSS in Journey were of a personal nature.
As I also explained to u later after the firing when u asked me privately, I was upset w/Jeff being fired b/c of the horrible way it was handled. He deserved a LOT better than he got for bailing them out last year & doing a ton of PR w/the fans.
I agree. It was handled in a really cowardly and tacky way. But you clearly feel it was right for both JSS and Journey that they went their different ways - so stop pretending to be so outraged that he isn't in the band anymore.
For me, it tarnishes it. For u, it doesn't. Great. Ur the kind of fan they want. I'm obviously not.
And yet here you are on the Journey forum talking about Journey night after night. You're just another Journey obsessive who can't let go no matter what the band do but you haven't even got the self-awareness to realise it.
Where have I rewritten Journey's history? Please point that out to me, would u?
By trying to minimize Schon and Cain's talent and contributions to the band in much the same way that Augeri fans tried to do about Perry. The lines you use are virtually identical to the cultish nonsense I used to read on BT all the time..."Oh, Journey would have been just as successful without Perry"..."Perry wasn't that talented after all". Just a lot of crap to prop up the guy they were obsessing about.
Hysterical? No. Just unhappy. If u equate hysteria w/unhappiness then u must live a very flat life.
No, I equate hysteria with wild, irrational and abusive posts that barely make any sense at all.