Well, Red, FAVORITE drummers is a whole 'nother animal!!
In my opinion, not only does SKILL come into play, but also TONE!!!
Got to give the top slot to the late John Bonham...such tone, and such power!!
I also like Vinny Appice (sorry Carmine)...He can really lay down a beat, and has a powerful tone as well.
My 3rd choice is Michael Derosier from Heart (late 70's, early 80's)...He really brought a lot to the Sister's Wilson...
Alex Van Halen...His tone is unique, and his cymbal work (especially hi-hat) I like too...
Kenny Aronoff and Steve Jordan...not so much Melodic Rock, but I dig their high "pingy" snare drums...
I forgot to put Neil Peart high up in the ranks, too!! He's probably 2nd choice under John Bonham.
"Who am I?...Why am I here? the late Admiral Stockdale (Ross Perot Vice-Presidential debate)