Moderator: Andrew
Clasicrockldy wrote:I will put this flat out to the point without talking in circles........... do you like this lineup or not?![]()
AR wrote:I will put this flat out to the point without talking in circles........... do you like this lineup or not?
Ah, what do we care? 1st post. Probably another water buffalo from BT that found out the truth is over here.
AR wrote:I will put this flat out to the point without talking in circles........... do you like this lineup or not?
Ah, what do we care? 1st post. Probably another water buffalo from BT that found out the truth is over here.
kctdaniels wrote:AR wrote:I will put this flat out to the point without talking in circles........... do you like this lineup or not?
Ah, what do we care? 1st post. Probably another water buffalo from BT that found out the truth is over here.
guessing
some kind of insult?
Just an op.
nothing else.
I went to the two shows bc of this place. have read here a lot. came back around about june, bc of scandal. got excited bc of excitement around here about new lineup.
no regrets. glad i went. just didn't float my boat.
obviously in minority here, which is fine with me. just throwing my op as well
we don't all have to wear rose glasses, do we
need a new pair, if so
kctdaniels wrote:I've just seen
this lineup twice
and i must say,
he ain't no perry
mean no ill will,. by all
rights ths lineup should be even
better. standing them next to each other, new
guys is in reality cuter, sexier, much more
rock & roll, much cooler... than perry ever was
but there is an intrensic with perry,
an intrensic with Neal and perry together
that creates an unexplainable heat,
new guy is probably more palatble with masses, critics
but what ever it is that made me not care how uncool it
was to love this band, that magic that made the music rise
above the mass palatable rest,
it is not here.
Not sure it can be again
closest would be for perry to work his ass, off and get his self and esp his voice in shape, for jrny to find an amazing producer that can pull out the best and flush the crap
if, if, if
lot of ifs and egos and mountains
but i'm sry. the heat is gone.
neal is still amazing enough to keep the embers burning, but ...
ps. not about any loyalty to any one. I'd love it if they could recapture something
but i just don't feel it. a lot of people I know don't get it. like better than last lineup, but still nothing to go knock one off their seat.
just one op in this crowd of believers
kc
Clasicrockldy wrote:kctdaniels wrote:AR wrote:I will put this flat out to the point without talking in circles........... do you like this lineup or not?
Ah, what do we care? 1st post. Probably another water buffalo from BT that found out the truth is over here.
guessing
some kind of insult?
Just an op.
nothing else.
I went to the two shows bc of this place. have read here a lot. came back around about june, bc of scandal. got excited bc of excitement around here about new lineup.
no regrets. glad i went. just didn't float my boat.
obviously in minority here, which is fine with me. just throwing my op as well
we don't all have to wear rose glasses, do we
need a new pair, if so
Don't wear rose colored glasses here. Doesn't look good on my face.![]()
Anyway, I am a Journey realist, and JSS has the powerhouse pipes to sing the songs. Nuff said.
dcvader wrote:AR wrote:I will put this flat out to the point without talking in circles........... do you like this lineup or not?
Ah, what do we care? 1st post. Probably another water buffalo from BT that found out the truth is over here.
kctdaniels wrote:I've just seen
this lineup twice
and i must say,
he ain't no perry
mean no ill will,. by all
rights ths lineup should be even
better. standing them next to each other, new
guys is in reality cuter, sexier, much more
rock & roll, much cooler... than perry ever was
but there is an intrensic with perry,
an intrensic with Neal and perry together
that creates an unexplainable heat,
new guy is probably more palatble with masses, critics
but what ever it is that made me not care how uncool it
was to love this band, that magic that made the music rise
above the mass palatable rest,
it is not here.
Not sure it can be again
closest would be for perry to work his ass, off and get his self and esp his voice in shape, for jrny to find an amazing producer that can pull out the best and flush the crap
if, if, if
lot of ifs and egos and mountains
but i'm sry. the heat is gone.
neal is still amazing enough to keep the embers burning, but ...
ps. not about any loyalty to any one. I'd love it if they could recapture something
but i just don't feel it. a lot of people I know don't get it. like better than last lineup, but still nothing to go knock one off their seat.
just one op in this crowd of believers
kc
dcvader wrote:AR wrote:I will put this flat out to the point without talking in circles........... do you like this lineup or not?
Ah, what do we care? 1st post. Probably another water buffalo from BT that found out the truth is over here.
kctdaniels wrote:I've just seen
this lineup twice
and i must say,
he ain't no perry
mean no ill will,. by all
rights ths lineup should be even
better. standing them next to each other, new
guys is in reality cuter, sexier, much more
rock & roll, much cooler... than perry ever was
but there is an intrensic with perry,
an intrensic with Neal and perry together
that creates an unexplainable heat,
new guy is probably more palatble with masses, critics
but what ever it is that made me not care how uncool it
was to love this band, that magic that made the music rise
above the mass palatable rest,
it is not here.
Not sure it can be again
closest would be for perry to work his ass, off and get his self and esp his voice in shape, for jrny to find an amazing producer that can pull out the best and flush the crap
if, if, if
lot of ifs and egos and mountains
but i'm sry. the heat is gone.
neal is still amazing enough to keep the embers burning, but ...
ps. not about any loyalty to any one. I'd love it if they could recapture something
but i just don't feel it. a lot of people I know don't get it. like better than last lineup, but still nothing to go knock one off their seat.
just one op in this crowd of believers
kc
fred_journeyman wrote:Okay, so you're saying simply that you don't see the kind of "heat" that existed between Neal and Perry in the current line up? Is that a good summation?
Thanks for sharing your opinion.
Clasicrockldy wrote:fred_journeyman wrote:Okay, so you're saying simply that you don't see the kind of "heat" that existed between Neal and Perry in the current line up? Is that a good summation?
Thanks for sharing your opinion.
Fred, I flat out asked them if they liked this lineup or not. They said not.
Okay, so you're saying simply that you don't see the kind of "heat" that existed between Neal and Perry in the current line up? Is that a good summation?
Thanks for sharing your opinion.
kctdaniels wrote:I've just seen
this lineup twice
and i must say,
he ain't no perry
mean no ill will,. by all
rights ths lineup should be even
better. standing them next to each other, new
guys is in reality cuter, sexier, much more
rock & roll, much cooler... than perry ever was
but there is an intrensic with perry,
an intrensic with Neal and perry together
that creates an unexplainable heat,
new guy is probably more palatble with masses, critics
but what ever it is that made me not care how uncool it
was to love this band, that magic that made the music rise
above the mass palatable rest,
it is not here.
Not sure it can be again
closest would be for perry to work his ass, off and get his self and esp his voice in shape, for jrny to find an amazing producer that can pull out the best and flush the crap
if, if, if
lot of ifs and egos and mountains
but i'm sry. the heat is gone.
neal is still amazing enough to keep the embers burning, but ...
ps. not about any loyalty to any one. I'd love it if they could recapture something
but i just don't feel it. a lot of people I know don't get it. like better than last lineup, but still nothing to go knock one off their seat.
just one op in this crowd of believers
kc
AR wrote:I will put this flat out to the point without talking in circles........... do you like this lineup or not?
Ah, what do we care? 1st post. Probably another water buffalo from BT that found out the truth is over here.
fred_journeyman wrote:Clasicrockldy wrote:fred_journeyman wrote:Okay, so you're saying simply that you don't see the kind of "heat" that existed between Neal and Perry in the current line up? Is that a good summation?
Thanks for sharing your opinion.
Fred, I flat out asked them if they liked this lineup or not. They said not.
No, he/she said he/she LIKED them, but didn't LOVE them.
brywool wrote:Let's hear him sing Open Arms, Faithfully, and Where Were You to name a few.
Jeff's a great singer, but in the range department, he falls short.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 44 guests