The_Noble_Cause wrote:The fans that brought TapeGate to light saved the band. That is fact.
That’s YOUR perception of what happened. Ultimately, JOURNEY saved themselves. They were held hostage by hefty contracts, a fading vocalist, and overly emotional, obsessive fans who couldn’t consider the big picture.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:Everyone connected to the band knows it, and some in private have even admitted it.
Anything said in private should stay that way. If admissions were made in private then you’ve broken trust therefore how can anyone trust your claim?
Ultimately, we hear/see/taste/touch what we WANT to. In certain settings words can easily be misconstrued. Did you personally hear these admissions? Who said them? What exactly did they say? If you’re going to break the trust and make the claim, then go all the way and provide the details.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:Aside from inspiring bellowing laughter in key band members, whenever you flippantly write me or Deano off as “delusional”, you also serve to undermine fans who acted in the best interest of fellow fans such as yourself.
Which key band members are laughing? Have you heard them laugh? Have they told you that they’re laughing? Again, back up your claims. If I’m offended and retract my JOURNEY fan club membership I doubt it will be of any consequence.
Unlike how it’s been applied to me countless times here I use the term "delusional" appropriately. In this instance I’m referring to the delusion that you claim to be the “saviors” of JOURNEY.
In REALITY what you’ve done is:
Post on the internet in the form of blogs and forums what you believed to be true regarding the use of tapes.
The Messianic heights to which you’ve taken this is textbook delusional.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:You may briefly feel you’ve re-gained the upperhand by marginalizing or even denying what occurred, but the truth is you remain just as locked outside in the cold as ever before. You see, that’s how TapeGate first spread. Concerned fans who *knew*, benevolently contacted other fans and so on, and so forth.
I’ve made myself abundantly clear that I’m a concerned fan. I’m so concerned that I will NOT pass judgment without a clear understanding of the MOTIVE for tapes.
NO ONE (including the famous noone) has EVER disclosed the MOTIVE. The motive may be entirely justifiable. Until I know what it was I can NOT and will NOT do what you have done which is to appoint yourself as judge, jury, and executioner.
JSS recently hinted at part of the motive when he commented that had JE lost his voice then DL would’ve dropped the tour without hesitation and “screwed” JOURNEY out of future earnings. This seems to indicate that JOURNEY was simply trying to maintain their contracts in good faith. This may be perceived as callously screwing the fans for the love of money. In reality, people are BIOLOGICAL and can’t always perform. That’s why Broadway and theatre use seconds in case of illness. That’s why artists have ALWAYS and will continue to use pre-recordings. Ours is a capitalistic society and sometimes that takes precedence over being a noble artist.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:If you’re asking yourself how come you never heard about it, maybe next time you should try reposing a little faith in your fellow fan, instead of prefabricated sanitized PR answers that never come (or in this case, come months after the squall has passed).
I’m not asking myself that question. I did hear about it from the get-go.
This isn’t a matter of faith. It’s a matter of motive.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:Even Andrew disliked Ross’s statement. What does that tell you? Andrew has dropped more breadcrumbs along the way for fans like you perennially stuck behind the 8-ball than Hansel, Gretel, and Stove Top combined.
I didn’t see where Andrew was explicit as to why he disliked Ross’ statement. You’re suggesting that Ross was lying and that Andrew concurs. Maybe he can clarify.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:Aside from bold-faced lying, Ross is also being very dismissive of Deano; a bud of mine and the man largely responsible for saving the band.
From the photos I’ve seen Dean is indeed large however I would again argue that saying he’s largely responsible for saving the band is delusional.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:Again, that is fact, and those same words have been uttered by members of the band themselves.
Please post who, when, and where.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:Ummm, Ross wasn’t talking anything substantive or making any point that should be treated with reverence.
That’s your opinion which seems to carry little water considering the uproar that his comments have caused.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:Even the usually tacit Andrew felt the need to express disapproval at Ross’s comments. I think Andrew, a music insider whose annals of knowledge know no corporal bounds, is in a much better position to judge what is an equitable statement when it comes to TapeGate, don’t you?
Now Andrew is the Second Coming, too. I respect Andrew as much as anyone but come on – I know you’re being facetious about knowing no corporal bounds but even so the reality is that no one including him has provided a comprehensive, authoritative report that proves the FACTS – ALL OF THEM INCLUDING MOTIVE – behind Tapegate.
Maybe he’s working on it…
FyreWyngz wrote:So why don't they just surrender already and let you and others manage them - OR ELSE.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:I don’t want to manage them. I just want them to do right by their fans.
OR ELSE.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:Putting a grinding halt to lip-synching was the first step.
Now if Ross truly has his heart set on making further amends with the fanbase, well, call me crazy, but I fail to see more untempered deceit as the best course of option.
There’s that OR ELSE stuff again.
OR ELSE destroys your “sincere” claims of doing right by the fans!!!
Ross is trying to do right by the fans and you’re threatening him for the simple fact that you’ve placed YOURSELF and Dean above the fans. Even considering Dean’s expanding girth the reality is that the fan base is BIGGER than you and Dean put together. I know that must be difficult for a Messiah to comprehend but you’ve got to try!
I agree that Ross’ statements were contrived to make amends with the fan base therefore if you REALLY cared about the fans you would permit Ross to do his job!
FyreWyngz wrote:I come here to talk about JOURNEY.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:No you don’t.
I believe my posts speak for themselves.
FyreWyngz wrote:You know - THE BAND. This place has become less about JOURNEY and more about certain people including yourself.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:Though I think Andrew runs a damn fine website, due to other commitments, my post quotient has been highly reduced lately, so this comment has no basis in reality.
Uh, yeah…
The_Noble_Cause wrote:Though if you’d like, Deano and I would be more than happy to give you a swirly and send your shorts riding up the flagpole.
There’s no way you and Dean could give me a swirly as his aforementioned girth prohibits the 3 of us from being in a stall at the same time. As for shorts up the flagpole - I don’t wear any. Free and unfettered am I.
FyreWyngz wrote:BOTTOM LINE: Ross takes on the question and you don't like the answer so you threaten him.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:He lied.
If he keeps lying, Deano can put the blog up again and bring a macrocosm of woes crashing down upon their unsuspecting heads.
All for the fans – right? Has nothing to do with his lies making you look bad.
NAH.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:They screwed the fans once before, and the fans screwed them back ten-fold.
Why on earth would we hesitate to do it again?
Truth be told, I’m actually kinda looking forward to it.
Sounds like you WANT it. You NEED it so that you can validate your miserable existence.
Yeeesh.