Live vs. Studio

by **mikemarrs** » Sat Dec 08, 2007 9:13 am

line of fire and stay awhile sound better to me live on captured than on departure.i like the live version of wheel in the sky better live than on infinity.i also like just the same way better on captured live than on evolution.something about the live versions because they seem to put more energy and emotion into it.i've never had greatest hits live so i can't comment on that.after greatest hits in '88 and time3 in ''92 i never bought any journey releases after that but before that journey is solid gold.i've never had trial by fire,greatest hits live,arrival,red 13 or generations.journey to me ceased to exist right after raised on radio.1978-1986 was the golden era.

by **Rick** » Sat Dec 08, 2007 9:17 am

mikemarrs wrote:line of fire and stay awhile sound better to me live on captured than on departure.i like the live version of wheel in the sky better live than on infinity.i also like just the same way better on captured live than on evolution.something about the live versions because they seem to put more energy and emotion into it.i've never had greatest hits live so i can't comment on that.after greatest hits in '88 and time3 in ''92 i never bought any journey releases after that but before that journey is solid gold.i've never had trial by fire,greatest hits live,arrival,red 13 or generations.journey to me ceased to exist right after raised on radio.1978-1986 was the golden era.

Maybe the live versions are better because they've played the songs many more times by then and have gotten smoother at them, plus have changed them up a bit, and usually always for the better.

by **Johnny Mohawk** » Sat Dec 08, 2007 9:43 am

Deb wrote;
Here ya go. Stand Up (FTLSM 02-13-95 NJ)

http://download.yousendit.com/774FFAD41C957CBC

Thank you!
I had no idea that he ever played that one live.
In fact, in all honesty, I don't think I would have believed it without hearing it myself.

by **mikemarrs** » Sat Dec 08, 2007 9:46 am

yep rick.watching your clip partys over live.pretty good stuff....

by **Rick** » Sat Dec 08, 2007 9:48 am

mikemarrs wrote:yep rick.watching your clip partys over live.pretty good stuff....

I've got some good ones on there, check them out.

by **Deb** » Sat Dec 08, 2007 9:52 am

Johnny Mohawk wrote:
Deb wrote;
Here ya go. Stand Up (FTLSM 02-13-95 NJ)

http://download.yousendit.com/774FFAD41C957CBC

Thank you!
I had no idea that he ever played that one live.
In fact, in all honesty, I don't think I would have believed it without hearing it myself.

Actually thank you too, that was a treat to listen to again.

by **conversationpc** » Sat Dec 08, 2007 10:02 am

Deb wrote:Just curious what other peoples opinions are on live vs. studio. Is there certain Journey songs you much prefer live than the studio version or is there live songs you've heard that just can't come close to the studio version?

My favorite Journey tune is "Rubicon". That being said, it just doesn't usually seem to work as well live, for some reason.

by **lidobar** » Sat Dec 08, 2007 10:23 am

Deb wrote:Just curious what other peoples opinions are on live vs. studio. Is there certain Journey songs you much prefer live than the studio version or is there live songs you've heard that just can't come close to the studio version?

There is quite a bit of Perry-era Journey that once I have heard it live has won me over the studio version. Here's a few and will add more as I think of them. Lovin Touchin Squeezin IMO comes across much better live than studio, has more of a bluesy/sexy swagger when played live. DayDream is another one that sold me over studio version. And surprisingly Perry's Stand Up Before It's Too Late from FTLOSM was one I could take or leave until I heard it live, love it much better live.

Only the Young is one that I don't think I've ever heard a live version come close to the studio version.

Back talk sounded better live as well as the song Escape.

by **somethingtohide** » Sat Dec 08, 2007 10:38 am

TVL wrote:
somethingtohide wrote:I've heard a boot of Patiently that for me is the most beautiful Perry vocal ever.

Don't have the boot myself and not even sure when it was recorded...ethreal in it's beauty.

Merry Christmas!

Patiently~ Houston Live 1980

http://download.yousendit.com/5085DB024D30EA18

Beautiful!

Thank you.

by **mikemarrs** » Sat Dec 08, 2007 11:30 am

conversationpc wrote:
Deb wrote:Just curious what other peoples opinions are on live vs. studio. Is there certain Journey songs you much prefer live than the studio version or is there live songs you've heard that just can't come close to the studio version?

My favorite Journey tune is "Rubicon". That being said, it just doesn't usually seem to work as well live, for some reason.

love rubicon too.one of the last songs where the neal guitar is heavy and upfront.of course the next phase for them was raised on radio which was drowned in keyboards with a more poppy type sound.

by **Blueskies** » Sat Dec 08, 2007 12:27 pm

somethingtohide wrote:
TVL wrote:
somethingtohide wrote:I've heard a boot of Patiently that for me is the most beautiful Perry vocal ever.

Don't have the boot myself and not even sure when it was recorded...ethreal in it's beauty.

Merry Christmas!

Patiently~ Houston Live 1980

http://download.yousendit.com/5085DB024D30EA18

Beautiful!

Thank you.

No problem.

by **tammy** » Sat Dec 08, 2007 6:09 pm

Are we talking about vocals? I can't tell much of a difference in instruments.
I like both studio and Live - some just have different moods. My fave J. song is "Still They Ride" and I love the studio version, but when I heard the Philly Live, I was kinda disappointed - it sounded "too up"...then I heard the Budokan Live and I absolutely LOVE it. He captured the right mood for the song.
Patiently Live is incredible, but I also love the studio.
All I know is that SP was just as amazing Live as recorded...and, he could run around & sing perfectly, too!

I need more boots.

by m » Sun Dec 09, 2007 2:30 am

TVL wrote:
Johnny Mohawk wrote:
TVL wrote;
I'll save you the trouble, Deb...I've got it right here.

Here ya go, Johnny...
Lincoln Brewster did a really good solo in this.

Somewhere Theres Hope~ FTLOSM, New Jersey
http://download.yousendit.com/24DDA0211DCAAE2B

Actually, we were talking about "Stand Up (Before It's Too Late)".
Opps!..sorry...had that one ready to go for someone else and mixed 'em up! ...but I see Deb got ya.

actually, that link IS Stand up! not Somewhere.. just wrong label (in case the other one runs out...) thanks TVL & Deb!!!

by **Blueskies** » Sun Dec 09, 2007 2:35 am

Thats what happens when you start multi-tasking at a rediculous level! :lol:

anyway, your welcome

by **scarygirl** » Sun Dec 09, 2007 2:36 am

conversationpc wrote:
Deb wrote:Just curious what other peoples opinions are on live vs. studio. Is there certain Journey songs you much prefer live than the studio version or is there live songs you've heard that just can't come close to the studio version?

My favorite Journey tune is "Rubicon". That being said, it just doesn't usually seem to work as well live, for some reason.

I love Rubicon. I also love Rezza Del Soul. Hope I'm saying it right. I don't understand why people don't like thats SONG. His phrasing there is top notch. The way he sings, BAAAA D lands gives me chills.

Website · by **FishinMagician** » Sun Dec 09, 2007 9:55 am

La Raza is awesome!

by **annie89509** » Sun Dec 09, 2007 6:41 pm

TVL wrote:
somethingtohide wrote:
TVL wrote:
somethingtohide wrote:I've heard a boot of Patiently that for me is the most beautiful Perry vocal ever.

Don't have the boot myself and not even sure when it was recorded...ethreal in it's beauty.

Merry Christmas!

Patiently~ Houston Live 1980

http://download.yousendit.com/5085DB024D30EA18

Beautiful!

Thank you.
No problem.

Patiently definitely was breathtaking when SP sang it live. The recorded version pales in comparison. Anyone has the '79 Comiskey Park Patiently to post? It's even better than this Houston version, imo. I'm afraid I'm a klutz when it comes to song sharing.

by **inaweofschon** » Mon Dec 10, 2007 1:57 am

TVL wrote:Merry Christmas!

Patiently~ Houston Live 1980

http://download.yousendit.com/5085DB024D30EA18

TVL!

Every time I see a part of this show appear I have to ask the poster if they have the whole show. If you do, I want to know if your copy has a good version of "Gonna Be Alright"? I have the whole show but on my copy that song has the cd skipping at the beginning. I have been trying to find a good copy of that song for years.

Can you help?

Thanks!

by **inaweofschon** » Mon Dec 10, 2007 2:00 am

annie89509 wrote:
TVL wrote:
somethingtohide wrote:
TVL wrote:
somethingtohide wrote:I've heard a boot of Patiently that for me is the most beautiful Perry vocal ever.

Don't have the boot myself and not even sure when it was recorded...ethreal in it's beauty.

Merry Christmas!

Patiently~ Houston Live 1980

http://download.yousendit.com/5085DB024D30EA18

Beautiful!

Thank you.
No problem.

Patiently definitely was breathtaking when SP sang it live. The recorded version pales in comparison. Anyone has the '79 Comiskey Park Patiently to post? It's even better than this Houston version, imo. I'm afraid I'm a klutz when it comes to song sharing.

I have this exact boot but mine is called "Chicago, August 1979" So either they are the same thing or mine is mislabeled. :?:

by **jrnyman28** » Mon Dec 10, 2007 8:31 am

scarygirl wrote: I also love Rezza Del Soul. Hope I'm saying it right. I don't understand why people don't like thats SONG. His phrasing there is top notch. The way he sings, BAAAA D lands gives me chills.

Thank You Steve Augeri for performing that song live!

by m » Mon Dec 10, 2007 8:33 am

jrnyman28 wrote:
scarygirl wrote: I also love Rezza Del Soul. Hope I'm saying it right. I don't understand why people don't like thats SONG. His phrasing there is top notch. The way he sings, BAAAA D lands gives me chills.

Thank You Steve Augeri for performing that song live!

is there a boot?

by **conversationpc** » Mon Dec 10, 2007 8:38 am

lifer wrote:
jrnyman28 wrote:
scarygirl wrote: I also love Rezza Del Soul. Hope I'm saying it right. I don't understand why people don't like thats SONG. His phrasing there is top notch. The way he sings, BAAAA D lands gives me chills.

Thank You Steve Augeri for performing that song live!

is there a boot?

It's on the 2001 DVD. Best song on the disc, in my opinion.

by **BobbyinTN** » Mon Dec 10, 2007 9:04 am

I love live shows, but I'm all about the studio recordings. I love hearing EVERYTHIHNG and not just two instruments and I love the ideas that go into studio versions.

by **Blueskies** » Mon Dec 10, 2007 12:07 pm

inaweofschon wrote:
TVL wrote:Merry Christmas!

Patiently~ Houston Live 1980

http://download.yousendit.com/5085DB024D30EA18

TVL!

Every time I see a part of this show appear I have to ask the poster if they have the whole show. If you do, I want to know if your copy has a good version of "Gonna Be Alright"? I have the whole show but on my copy that song has the cd skipping at the beginning. I have been trying to find a good copy of that song for years.

Can you help?

Thanks!

No, sadly I don't have that whole show. I only have a few of the songs from that one thanks to others here that posted them before. I'm sorry I can't help you but someone here will have it.

by **Deb** » Mon Dec 10, 2007 2:47 pm

TVL wrote:
inaweofschon wrote:
TVL wrote:Merry Christmas!

Patiently~ Houston Live 1980

http://download.yousendit.com/5085DB024D30EA18

TVL!

Every time I see a part of this show appear I have to ask the poster if they have the whole show. If you do, I want to know if your copy has a good version of "Gonna Be Alright"? I have the whole show but on my copy that song has the cd skipping at the beginning. I have been trying to find a good copy of that song for years.

Can you help?

Thanks!
No, sadly I don't have that whole show. I only have a few of the songs from that one thanks to others here that posted them before. I'm sorry I can't help you but someone here will have it.

Are you sure it is Houston 80 you have? Gonna Be Alright? Do you mean She Makes Me Feel Alright? That one is on the Comisky Park 79 and a couple other 78 & 79 shows, but it's not on the Houston 80 one? What is the setlist you have. The Houston 80 one I have has following set list:

Intro
Departure
Majestic
Where Were You
Just the Same Way
Lovin You Is Easy
La Do Da - drum solo
break/interview -SP
Too Late
Kahoutek
People and Places
interview -SP
Dixie Highway
Walks Like A Lady
break/interview -SP
Winds of March
Feeling That Way
Anytime
interview -SP
Line Of Fire
Lovin Touchin Squeezin
Wheel In The Sky
Any Way You Want It
interview -sp
Patiently
Opened The Door
Precious Time

by **sniper16** » Tue Dec 11, 2007 1:27 am

line of fire really rocks live

MR

Live vs. Studio

Re: Live vs. Studio

Re: Live vs. Studio

Re: Live vs. Studio

Re: Live vs. Studio

Re: Live vs. Studio

Re: Live vs. Studio

Re: Live vs. Studio

Who is online