Moderator: Andrew
Slander wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:[]
Are you out of your mind?
It's not Andrew's responsibility to follow up with artists on OTHER people's interviews, especially not just because YOU don't like the way the 3rd party interview portrays Frankie Sullivan.
I think Andrew might even agree with me on this. I believe it is a journalist responsiblity to do follow up if you run a piece that accuses someone else of being a criminal. JJ flat out did that. It's one thing to say you don't like somebody..yadda..yadda..yadda...it's another to accuse someone of illegalities as JJ did. Andrew did the right thing and tried to get the other side. Frankie Sullivan declined to dignify the garbabe coming out of JJ's mouth. What is so insane about trying to get both sides of a story RED? RED what newspapers do you read? THE CUBAN TIMES!
Slander wrote:axecrew wrote:Thank YOU for playing, game,set,match.
Ok folks that concludes today's entertaiment,tune in again when slander finds another way to get paid by the Saint.
No that doeesn't settle anything axe. So you are telling me it was the promoters idea when JJ was parading around as Survivor?
axecrew wrote: Where was that GREAT journalistic integrity when sullivan came on here and blasted JJ? Did you scream then for Andrew to get JJ's side of things? I believe you laughed your ass off and said that it served him right
Slander wrote:[quote="Slander"
Why can't you answer the question: If JJ is such a legend than why do promoters have cloak him in Survivor?
axecrew wrote:Slander wrote:axecrew wrote:Thank YOU for playing, game,set,match.
Ok folks that concludes today's entertaiment,tune in again when slander finds another way to get paid by the Saint.
No that doeesn't settle anything axe. So you are telling me it was the promoters idea when JJ was parading around as Survivor?
![]()
![]()
![]()
NO that was the circut court judge who threw out the lawsuit and awarded JJ the right to call himself Survivor "featuring Jimi Jamison" since Survivor released compilation albums by that name. And speaking of those albums...why did Survivor put out those albums with JJ solo songs on there? After all it was a SURVIVOR album right? Not a Jimi Jamison album.
Why is Paul Stanley billed as Paul Stanley of Kiss? Because that is what he's mostly known for. So why shouldn't JJ use all of his hard work and noteriety in Survivor when billing himself? I don't call it riding Survivor's coattails,I call it reminding people of what he has done.
When the Saint goes and works on other projects...is he Frankie Sullivan of Survivor or is he just Frankie Sullivan?
Face it Survivor isn't nor was it ever big enough that the members were known outside of the band like say KISS, The Beatles etc.....so each and EVERY memeber has used that connection to let people know of their work in that band,including the saint. So you can lose that complaint also he's not "riding the coattails" anymore the the Saint is or does.
Bottomline is outside of Survivor...Saint and JJ aren't known by name,just like most people couldn't tell you what individuals recorded the song "High on You",some might not even know it was Survivor. They only know the song.
Red13JoePa wrote:axecrew wrote: Where was that GREAT journalistic integrity when sullivan came on here and blasted JJ? Did you scream then for Andrew to get JJ's side of things? I believe you laughed your ass off and said that it served him right
Hm.
A question worth repeating.
Slander wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:axecrew wrote: Where was that GREAT journalistic integrity when sullivan came on here and blasted JJ? Did you scream then for Andrew to get JJ's side of things? I believe you laughed your ass off and said that it served him right
Hm.
A question worth repeating.
When did FS blast JJ? only joined the board in 2006. I haven't seen anything like that. In fact FS has always taken the high road.
Joe Vana wrote:axecrew wrote:Slander wrote:axecrew wrote:Thank YOU for playing, game,set,match.
Ok folks that concludes today's entertaiment,tune in again when slander finds another way to get paid by the Saint.
No that doeesn't settle anything axe. So you are telling me it was the promoters idea when JJ was parading around as Survivor?
![]()
![]()
![]()
NO that was the circut court judge who threw out the lawsuit and awarded JJ the right to call himself Survivor "featuring Jimi Jamison" since Survivor released compilation albums by that name. And speaking of those albums...why did Survivor put out those albums with JJ solo songs on there? After all it was a SURVIVOR album right? Not a Jimi Jamison album.
Why is Paul Stanley billed as Paul Stanley of Kiss? Because that is what he's mostly known for. So why shouldn't JJ use all of his hard work and noteriety in Survivor when billing himself? I don't call it riding Survivor's coattails,I call it reminding people of what he has done.
When the Saint goes and works on other projects...is he Frankie Sullivan of Survivor or is he just Frankie Sullivan?
Face it Survivor isn't nor was it ever big enough that the members were known outside of the band like say KISS, The Beatles etc.....so each and EVERY memeber has used that connection to let people know of their work in that band,including the saint. So you can lose that complaint also he's not "riding the coattails" anymore the the Saint is or does.
Bottomline is outside of Survivor...Saint and JJ aren't known by name,just like most people couldn't tell you what individuals recorded the song "High on You",some might not even know it was Survivor. They only know the song.
Hi Axecrew....I HAVE a copy of the order...he CANNOT use the name in ANY WAY, EVER...I just wanted to clear up any misconceptions....not fan any flames....
Now ALL of you....go to this....http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ShlRQENdqZo
I think this horse is beaten, dead and buried....
Red13JoePa wrote:There's an interview on this very site (Empires era) where Jamison claims he WON the lawsuit and the right to use "Survivor" within certain specific contexts.
Red13JoePa wrote:There's an interview on this very site (Empires era) where Jamison claims he WON the lawsuit and the right to use "Survivor" within certain specific contexts.
Red13JoePa wrote:You have a copy of the order?
Joe Vana wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:You have a copy of the order?
It's public here in Illinois...
I just feel bad that all this energy is being wasted on this stuff....Jamo is going to play a few dates oversees with a backing band...it's almost kareoke....go ahead....have a ball...if people pay to see it, good for them.....if not, ok too....JJ is doing what he feels he needs to do I guess....Frankie is STILL Survivor, in name and in a physical band...they still have drawing power anywhere in the world.....the only negative is this....when people in the UK see a banner lets say a year from now they will have to ask themselves, is it Survivor (Sullivan, Droubay, Robin, Grove, Ozello) or Jimi Jamison and a backing band.....
That is my problem with this....it's a dillution of the brand......and the band...
JV
Red13JoePa wrote:What Jamison's doing is karaoke?
Did Sullivan's current McSurvivor linep start playing all originals with only current bandmembers?
A case could be made that Frankie's dilluting the "brand" as much as JJ or JP.
You actually think people in the UK will sitting there fretting that unless the current lineup they may not be seeing Survivor?
Richard Epps wrote:I am not fretting about this being Survivor or not,I am pleased that a memeber past or present is coming to our shores,
Red13JoePa wrote:Joe Vana wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:You have a copy of the order?
It's public here in Illinois...
I just feel bad that all this energy is being wasted on this stuff....Jamo is going to play a few dates oversees with a backing band...it's almost kareoke....go ahead....have a ball...if people pay to see it, good for them.....if not, ok too....JJ is doing what he feels he needs to do I guess....Frankie is STILL Survivor, in name and in a physical band...they still have drawing power anywhere in the world.....the only negative is this....when people in the UK see a banner lets say a year from now they will have to ask themselves, is it Survivor (Sullivan, Droubay, Robin, Grove, Ozello) or Jimi Jamison and a backing band.....
That is my problem with this....it's a dillution of the brand......and the band...
JV
What Jamison's doing is karaoke?
Did Sullivan's current McSurvivor linep start playing all originals with only current bandmembers?
A case could be made that Frankie's dilluting the "brand" as much as JJ or JP.
You actually think people in the UK will sitting there fretting that unless the current lineup they may not be seeing Survivor?
Red13JoePa wrote:Joe Vana wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:You have a copy of the order?
It's public here in Illinois...
I just feel bad that all this energy is being wasted on this stuff....Jamo is going to play a few dates oversees with a backing band...it's almost kareoke....go ahead....have a ball...if people pay to see it, good for them.....if not, ok too....JJ is doing what he feels he needs to do I guess....Frankie is STILL Survivor, in name and in a physical band...they still have drawing power anywhere in the world.....the only negative is this....when people in the UK see a banner lets say a year from now they will have to ask themselves, is it Survivor (Sullivan, Droubay, Robin, Grove, Ozello) or Jimi Jamison and a backing band.....
That is my problem with this....it's a dillution of the brand......and the band...
JV
What Jamison's doing is karaoke?
Did Sullivan's current McSurvivor linep start playing all originals with only current bandmembers?
A case could be made that Frankie's dilluting the "brand" as much as JJ or JP.
You actually think people in the UK will sitting there fretting that unless the current lineup they may not be seeing Survivor?
Richard Epps wrote:No probs this end, find the debate very interesting,no chance of second guessing Red, I am counting the days to the shows,hope they all go ahead as we have had a lot of cancelled shows here in the UK lately
Joe Vana wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:Joe Vana wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:You have a copy of the order?
It's public here in Illinois...
I just feel bad that all this energy is being wasted on this stuff....Jamo is going to play a few dates oversees with a backing band...it's almost kareoke....go ahead....have a ball...if people pay to see it, good for them.....if not, ok too....JJ is doing what he feels he needs to do I guess....Frankie is STILL Survivor, in name and in a physical band...they still have drawing power anywhere in the world.....the only negative is this....when people in the UK see a banner lets say a year from now they will have to ask themselves, is it Survivor (Sullivan, Droubay, Robin, Grove, Ozello) or Jimi Jamison and a backing band.....
That is my problem with this....it's a dillution of the brand......and the band...
JV
What Jamison's doing is karaoke?
Did Sullivan's current McSurvivor linep start playing all originals with only current bandmembers?
A case could be made that Frankie's dilluting the "brand" as much as JJ or JP.
You actually think people in the UK will sitting there fretting that unless the current lineup they may not be seeing Survivor?
Kareoke is a bit harsh....I am not familiar with Dante Fox....they may smoke.....I apologize for that remark.....
JV
axecrew wrote:Joe Vana wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:Joe Vana wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:You have a copy of the order?
It's public here in Illinois...
I just feel bad that all this energy is being wasted on this stuff....Jamo is going to play a few dates oversees with a backing band...it's almost kareoke....go ahead....have a ball...if people pay to see it, good for them.....if not, ok too....JJ is doing what he feels he needs to do I guess....Frankie is STILL Survivor, in name and in a physical band...they still have drawing power anywhere in the world.....the only negative is this....when people in the UK see a banner lets say a year from now they will have to ask themselves, is it Survivor (Sullivan, Droubay, Robin, Grove, Ozello) or Jimi Jamison and a backing band.....
That is my problem with this....it's a dillution of the brand......and the band...
JV
What Jamison's doing is karaoke?
Did Sullivan's current McSurvivor linep start playing all originals with only current bandmembers?
A case could be made that Frankie's dilluting the "brand" as much as JJ or JP.
You actually think people in the UK will sitting there fretting that unless the current lineup they may not be seeing Survivor?
Kareoke is a bit harsh....I am not familiar with Dante Fox....they may smoke.....I apologize for that remark.....
JV
Joe......Perry is known by his name alone just like Journey is...comparing Survivor to Journey and Jamison to Perry is unfair. Survivor NEVER to this day has had the recognition that Journey still receives to this day.
It's almost like comparing You and Mecca to Bobby Kimble and Toto.....most people ask are going to say who the fuck is Mecca and Joe Vana.
To my knowledge the order allowed Jimi to bill himself as I stated, now maybe something has changed in the last few years. Why don't you post us a link to that "public record" so we can all see it. It would be very helpful to us all,then either myself or slander will know if we are wrong.
BTW...What would posess you to go get yourself a copy of that order?
Journey/Survivor wrote:I've heard that Deep Purple's original lead vocalist Rod Evans had toured with a band that he was calling Deep Purple back in the early 1970's, and Deep Purple sued him over it.
Slander wrote:Journey/Survivor wrote:I've heard that Deep Purple's original lead vocalist Rod Evans had toured with a band that he was calling Deep Purple back in the early 1970's, and Deep Purple sued him over it.
Yeah kind of like Gallagher's brother touring as the comedian Gallagher. I have no problem with JJ touring as former Survivor vocalist but I have a problem when things get blurred. Listen I drove 8 hours in 2008 to see Survivor. Survivor was on my ticket stub! There was a pic of frankie, marc, etc. I show up and it's JJ with a band that seemed thrown together. JJ was fine. The band was not. I take issue with this. Sorry.
Return to Survivor / Jim Peterik / Toby Hitchcock / Pride Of Lions / Marc Scherer / Sir Jimi (RIP)
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 7 guests