Moderator: Andrew
MarcelJordan wrote:Funny to see someone thought Survivor was Glass Tiger. Geez!
MarcelJordan wrote:Jim will have no say in what Survivor does. He gave up the name (which paved the way for JJ to try to take it several years back). Frankie fought tooth and nail over Survivor's name.
Let's look at things in this perspective;The band still gets gigs, the regular Joe doesn't care who's on lead. Funny to see someone thought Survivor was Glass Tiger. Geez!
venomnation wrote:Just Why is sullivan (so it seems..) resurrecting this fiasco as survivor
Cheryl wrote:<<<Let me say first of all that Dave will always be the real Survivor to me, but without question Robin has been incredible and blows away Dave and Jimi both in terms of on stage performance (not singing).>>>
Are you kidding? I won a contest years ago to see Survivor, back when Dave was singing, first concert I ever walked out of....they did nothing to impress me, nothing....
I worked for Jimi for year's and attended many concerts and to say that Robin's stage performance blows jj away, pleaseeeeeeeeeeeee......Jimi always had the crowd eating out of his hands. He worked the crowd like a pro and continues to do so.
I know fans that have seen all 3 performer's...and they aren't spouting about his stage performance, they say he is a good singer and tries very hard, which I give him credit for that. Let me go youtube and see what I can find coz I gotta see someone outshine Jimi in performance and working a crowd coz he is one of the best at doing so.
I have yet to see Robin front Survivor, but from what I have been told he's nice, he's nice to the fans and very personable....having said all that, I just think that it is hard for any singer to come in and replace the original singer for the die hard fans....Dave to me, may be a nice guy, but I do not like his voice, don't ask me why, I just never have liked it....so in my eyes, even tho he was the original singer, he's not the one that I thought of when I think of Survivor.
I would like to know what Robin is doing on stage that blows Jimi away?
You almost make me want to go see Survivor just to see what you mean by this....almost...lol.
venomnation wrote:Big fan of the first four albums of survivor....big fan of bickler, honestly....think he's still got some chops to him.....love the jamison era, but I was a fan of jamison before he was in Survivor. I'd take EITHER ONE of them..at HALF of their ability..fronting Survivor, than this clown.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jzqvbt0KQ8Y
I realize WHO he is....and what he HAS done..but this just isn't survivor to me...no matter how much he poses...
My humble opinion..
Anyone else?
PianoMan1986 wrote:venomnation wrote:Big fan of the first four albums of survivor....big fan of bickler, honestly....think he's still got some chops to him.....love the jamison era, but I was a fan of jamison before he was in Survivor. I'd take EITHER ONE of them..at HALF of their ability..fronting Survivor, than this clown.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jzqvbt0KQ8Y
I realize WHO he is....and what he HAS done..but this just isn't survivor to me...no matter how much he poses...
My humble opinion..
Anyone else?
I agree with you 100%. Initially, it was Jimi's voice that caught my ear...then recently I came across Ever Since The World Began and I was floored by Bickler's performance (hence I want to complete my collection by getting his albums with the band too). Personally, Robin's a great ROCK singer and has a good range, but he doesn't have the SOUL aspect that Bickler and Jamison have. To me, it's basically Frankie Sullivan's Survivor and I have no desire to see them no matter how close they come to my town. Pretty much why I voted in the poll (Which version of Survivor do you want to see..?) that I would want to see a version with all of them and somebody else on guitar...
weatherman90 wrote:I have absolutely nothing against Robin, I'm sure he's a great guy. We all would prefer to see our favorite bands with as many original (or long-time) members intact as possible, and with Survivor it's just not happening to a big extent right now. It would be great to see a Survivor reunion at some point, maybe a tour with the whole gang and a 2 hour set with 1 hour of Dave and 1 hour with Jimi. Now I'm dreaming!
Anyway, I will still be supporting the current version of Survivor (seeing them on July 11 '09)
MarcelJordan wrote:Excellent and very welcoming intro there tigerseye224!
Glad to welcome you aboard here and even more so, you tried and saw what Robin brings to the table.![]()
Your comments are very similar to those who took the chance to see Survivor perform after Robin took the vocals lead. From low expectations to find their fears unfounded (well most of the fears LOL!).
I heard Eye first before embarking on my neverending Survivor fascination. Dave's voice pulled me in BUT Frankie's guitar style kept me coming back. Its the same with Journey for me.![]()
Later,
weatherman90 wrote:I have absolutely nothing against Robin, I'm sure he's a great guy. We all would prefer to see our favorite bands with as many original (or long-time) members intact as possible, and with Survivor it's just not happening to a big extent right now. It would be great to see a Survivor reunion at some point, maybe a tour with the whole gang and a 2 hour set with 1 hour of Dave and 1 hour with Jimi. Now I'm dreaming!
Anyway, I will still be supporting the current version of Survivor (seeing them on July 11 '09)
tigerseye224 wrote:MarcelJordan wrote:Excellent and very welcoming intro there tigerseye224!
Glad to welcome you aboard here and even more so, you tried and saw what Robin brings to the table.![]()
Your comments are very similar to those who took the chance to see Survivor perform after Robin took the vocals lead. From low expectations to find their fears unfounded (well most of the fears LOL!).
I heard Eye first before embarking on my neverending Survivor fascination. Dave's voice pulled me in BUT Frankie's guitar style kept me coming back. Its the same with Journey for me.![]()
Later,
Thanks for the warm welcome MarcelJordan!
Yeah, Robin far exceeded my expectations, and my friends thought they were so great that they wanted to see them again too. By that time, they only had one more concert, so we'll see what the coming summer concert season brings! Only can wonder what the mix with Robin's songwriting will do to the sound of Survivor. Whatever happens, I'll be a loyal fan till the end... hopefully a long time from now!
I didn't really discuss Frankie as far as vocalists go, but he certainly still has the magical Fender touch. They have one local concert date posted so far this coming summer, so I'll be there, supporting them whenever I can, just like the old days.
I like Journey too, but only saw them once in 1978 when they were hot at a large arena. Wish Survivor would join that bandwagon as an opener for Journey, especially as Arnel did such a great version of Ever Since the World Began with the Zoo. He could duet beautifully with Jimi, I'm sure. Survivor and Journey would be a phenomenal concert pair!
MarcelJordan wrote:tigerseye224 wrote:MarcelJordan wrote:Excellent and very welcoming intro there tigerseye224!
Glad to welcome you aboard here and even more so, you tried and saw what Robin brings to the table.![]()
Your comments are very similar to those who took the chance to see Survivor perform after Robin took the vocals lead. From low expectations to find their fears unfounded (well most of the fears LOL!).
I heard Eye first before embarking on my neverending Survivor fascination. Dave's voice pulled me in BUT Frankie's guitar style kept me coming back. Its the same with Journey for me.![]()
Later,
Thanks for the warm welcome MarcelJordan!
Yeah, Robin far exceeded my expectations, and my friends thought they were so great that they wanted to see them again too. By that time, they only had one more concert, so we'll see what the coming summer concert season brings! Only can wonder what the mix with Robin's songwriting will do to the sound of Survivor. Whatever happens, I'll be a loyal fan till the end... hopefully a long time from now!
I didn't really discuss Frankie as far as vocalists go, but he certainly still has the magical Fender touch. They have one local concert date posted so far this coming summer, so I'll be there, supporting them whenever I can, just like the old days.
I like Journey too, but only saw them once in 1978 when they were hot at a large arena. Wish Survivor would join that bandwagon as an opener for Journey, especially as Arnel did such a great version of Ever Since the World Began with the Zoo. He could duet beautifully with Jimi, I'm sure. Survivor and Journey would be a phenomenal concert pair!
Pleasure was all mine!
Im glad that Robin far exceeded your expectations. That's really telling that in the end these guys are professionals doing what they love to do, the main thing is go out there to the best of their abilities, to give others some enjoyment. I do remember Robin saying that he is a fan of Survivor's first three records in particular so he's no stranger to the music.
Its yet to be heard what FS and RM's collaboration will bring out when it comes to new music. Frankie said that he gets the same vibe with Robin as he had with JP when writing tunes so, we'll see whether they actually do show the new stuff sooner than later!
Wow, 1978 with Journey. With all due respect with Journey's music from '81 onwards, I think they were really a rock band in the true sense pre-jonathan cain. I love all the albums even the first ones actually more than the mid 80's onwards with the exception of Separate Ways (which is the ultimate ballad/rocker). I can only imagine what it was like for you.
MarcelJordan wrote:weatherman90 wrote:I have absolutely nothing against Robin, I'm sure he's a great guy. We all would prefer to see our favorite bands with as many original (or long-time) members intact as possible, and with Survivor it's just not happening to a big extent right now. It would be great to see a Survivor reunion at some point, maybe a tour with the whole gang and a 2 hour set with 1 hour of Dave and 1 hour with Jimi. Now I'm dreaming!
Anyway, I will still be supporting the current version of Survivor (seeing them on July 11 '09)
Excellent weatherman90! Looking forward to a review of that (7 months from now.)
Tito wrote:I'd go see the current version of survivor. However, I would love to see a Jim Peterik, Jimi Jamison, and Dave Bickler band that would tour in the summer festivals. Call it Survived or something like that.
MarcelJordan wrote:Tito wrote:I'd go see the current version of survivor. However, I would love to see a Jim Peterik, Jimi Jamison, and Dave Bickler band that would tour in the summer festivals. Call it Survived or something like that.
That would be interesting although I don't really see that working, without getting Frankie involved. It would have to a Survivor reunion for it to avoid any confusion.
Return to Survivor / Jim Peterik / Toby Hitchcock / Pride Of Lions / Marc Scherer / Sir Jimi (RIP)
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests