Liquid_Drummer wrote:This guys range in off the charts !! HOWEVER, it is too high and reminds me of a little girl screaming like when kids are playing or they get startled. This guy just seems like he is saying, "look at me, I can sing really, really high. He was obviously more worried about serving his ego than the music. That is what I hear anyway.
It was show-off only in Sheriff. Take a 19-year old guy with an exceptional voice out of freshman year of college and throw him in a studio, and that's what you get sometimes. By the time the Alias record was done, he had come down quite a bit except for choice locations (most of which were in that compilation), and is quite restrained and VERY effective on his solo album Dreamer's Road.
Curci certainly isn't the only one to do oversinging--and that post makes it worse than it really is, unless you just like to hear how high you can push the male voice. A lot of singers have been guilty of oversinging at one point or another from Hugo to John Farnham to Tony Harnell (who makes Curci sound like a baritone).
Truthfully, there IS a place in some songs where high notes can be done well without coming off as showboating--the outro of Why Can't This Night Go On Forever is a good example. The key, or talent, is knowing what songs and where it is appropriate to do vocal acrobatics....and when NOT to and just sing the melody.