Ehwmatt wrote:JasonD wrote:*Laura wrote:Not going to get into the death penalty banter here, but I'm going to say this: that girl who was kidnapped, abused and deprived of her rights to have a normal life...what if she was YOUR daughter? Would you flip the switch? Would you insert the needle? I sure as hell would.
Scumbags who destroy human beings and take away other people's freedom to live should not be allowed to live either.
I just believe that no one has a right to take a life except for God. If someone is put to death by an executioner for taking the life of another, than who is going to put to death the executioner for taking the life of the death row inmate? And who is going to put to death the person who ended the life of the executioner who ended the life of the original death row inmate....? & so on, & so on, & so forth .....?
An eye for an eye leaves everybody blind.
In purely logical terms, the executioner is acting in accordance with the dictates of public policy and society, which have decided said inmate should be put to death. A capital offender violated someone's right to life and in so doing, forfeited his own otherwise inviolable right to life and freedom, allowing the executioner to not be culpable or accountable to his own death sentence. Not to mention by the time the switch is being thrown or the needle is being inserted, the offender has exhausted all of his rights to due process and equal protection, something his victim(s) never got.
I understand the moral point you're trying to make, and for sure you're entitled to it, but that's a Grand Canyon of a logical pit you made there trying to make the executioner accountable the same way a capital offender would be...
I get what you're saying. I truly do. It's much in the same way that *Laura threw in the "What if it was YOUR daughter....?" line b/c I have a daughter who means the world to me & so I suppose that was my cue to change my stance.
If you're not a Christian or any other God-fearing spiritual person, then I don't expect you to understand. Now, I'm not referring to those so-called Christians out there who claim to be Christian, but in the very next breath yell "FRY THE BASTARD." I'm referring to actual Christians. Also, please don't think I don't know I'm opening up a whole Pandora's Box by saying what I just said & allowing every so-called Christian who is insulted by my last comment to come forth & throw their Bibles at me with venomous comments like, "If you're SO Christian, then how come you sleep with men....? yadda, yadda. I’m well aware of the repercussions, but that's an issue for another day and, no, I'm not trying to avoid the topic. It's just that Andrew gets pissed when I "go there," & so if you first clear it with Andrew, then I'll "go there." Otherwise, e'nuff said.
Back to the death penalty issue: I just believe that God's say-so outweighs that of the dictates of public policy & society. To me, the executioner IS just as accountable as the capital offender b/c, to me, killing is killing regardless of the context. If they are two separate entities to you, then everything else I say will be Greek b/c I'm speaking a different language.