
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VZNr5QiI ... re=related
Moderator: Andrew
G.I.Jim wrote:Since this is my favorite song, I HAD to post this version with Kelly! It's the best I think I've heard him sound. Yes, they did drop the song from it's original key, and although this version is SLOW AS HELL... it's still amazing! Best replacement they could have ever found for Lou.![]()
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VZNr5QiI ... re=related
conversationpc wrote:G.I.Jim wrote:Since this is my favorite song, I HAD to post this version with Kelly! It's the best I think I've heard him sound. Yes, they did drop the song from it's original key, and although this version is SLOW AS HELL... it's still amazing! Best replacement they could have ever found for Lou.![]()
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VZNr5QiI ... re=related
That's not bad but the live version from "Live at Deer Creek" with Lou is much better. That one has the same intro as this one does as well. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5MZiSntiI08
Another thing...The version with Hansen is about as live as the vocals on Journey's 2005 tour were.
G.I.Jim wrote:conversationpc wrote:G.I.Jim wrote:Since this is my favorite song, I HAD to post this version with Kelly! It's the best I think I've heard him sound. Yes, they did drop the song from it's original key, and although this version is SLOW AS HELL... it's still amazing! Best replacement they could have ever found for Lou.![]()
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VZNr5QiI ... re=related
That's not bad but the live version from "Live at Deer Creek" with Lou is much better. That one has the same intro as this one does as well. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5MZiSntiI08
Another thing...The version with Hansen is about as live as the vocals on Journey's 2005 tour were.
True about it not being live, but it's still awesome! I LOVE the "Live At Deer Creek" version, but again... I'm talking about the best KELLY version. Get with the program dammit!!!
conversationpc wrote:G.I.Jim wrote:conversationpc wrote:G.I.Jim wrote:Since this is my favorite song, I HAD to post this version with Kelly! It's the best I think I've heard him sound. Yes, they did drop the song from it's original key, and although this version is SLOW AS HELL... it's still amazing! Best replacement they could have ever found for Lou.![]()
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VZNr5QiI ... re=related
That's not bad but the live version from "Live at Deer Creek" with Lou is much better. That one has the same intro as this one does as well. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5MZiSntiI08
Another thing...The version with Hansen is about as live as the vocals on Journey's 2005 tour were.
True about it not being live, but it's still awesome! I LOVE the "Live At Deer Creek" version, but again... I'm talking about the best KELLY version. Get with the program dammit!!!
I knew what the program was. I just couldn't help one-upping that version.
conversationpc wrote:Another thing...The version with Hansen is about as live as the vocals on Journey's 2005 tour were.
cudaclan wrote:JSS is more than capable of performing Foreigner's catalog.
cudaclan wrote:JSS is more than capable of performing Foreigner's catalog.
Andrew wrote:conversationpc wrote:Another thing...The version with Hansen is about as live as the vocals on Journey's 2005 tour were.
Hansen is always 100% live and nothing else. Ever.
EDIT: Unless it is a promo video like this one
But on stage...it's always 100% real.
Andrew wrote:conversationpc wrote:Another thing...The version with Hansen is about as live as the vocals on Journey's 2005 tour were.
Hansen is always 100% live and nothing else. Ever.
EDIT: Unless it is a promo video like this one
But on stage...it's always 100% real.
BobbyinTN wrote:
I think every group with a tenor singer should take every song they have down at least a half a step when performing live. If Mr. Perry had done that years ago, he might not have encountered the problems he did.
Just an opinion from a tenor. LOL
kgdjpubs wrote:I agree with you, but one thing Foreigner did right by getting Kelly Hansen is finding someone who's natural range is debatedly HIGHER than Lou Gramm's voice was before the medical problems.
cudaclan wrote:JSS is more than capable of performing Foreigner's catalog.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:kgdjpubs wrote:I agree with you, but one thing Foreigner did right by getting Kelly Hansen is finding someone who's natural range is debatedly HIGHER than Lou Gramm's voice was before the medical problems.
No way. Maybe in his Hurricane days. Kelly can hit those glass shattering power notes when he has to - and does it quite well. But he keeps them in reserve and sings comfortably in his chest voice. Lou had a naturally high voice that would stop you cold in your tracks. We're talking a one-in-a-million set of pipes like Perry. There's a reason the new lineup has slowed certain songs down or done acoustic renditions, probably so Kelly has an easier time getting *up there* and hitting those highs. The difference between Lou in his prime and Kelly is most noticeable on Foreigner's last album. For much of "Can't Slow Down", Kelly sounds like Augeri on "Kiss me Softly" or something. It almost veers on boring and monotone. At it's worst, it sounds like a generic rocker voice. Kelly is the best replacement the band (and the fans) could have hoped for, but he's not higher pitched than vintage Lou.
Ehwmatt wrote:The_Noble_Cause wrote:kgdjpubs wrote:I agree with you, but one thing Foreigner did right by getting Kelly Hansen is finding someone who's natural range is debatedly HIGHER than Lou Gramm's voice was before the medical problems.
No way. Maybe in his Hurricane days. Kelly can hit those glass shattering power notes when he has to - and does it quite well. But he keeps them in reserve and sings comfortably in his chest voice. Lou had a naturally high voice that would stop you cold in your tracks. We're talking a one-in-a-million set of pipes like Perry. There's a reason the new lineup has slowed certain songs down or done acoustic renditions, probably so Kelly has an easier time getting *up there* and hitting those highs. The difference between Lou in his prime and Kelly is most noticeable on Foreigner's last album. For much of "Can't Slow Down", Kelly sounds like Augeri on "Kiss me Softly" or something. It almost veers on boring and monotone. At it's worst, it sounds like a generic rocker voice. Kelly is the best replacement the band (and the fans) could have hoped for, but he's not higher pitched than vintage Lou.
I'm not sure vintage Lou is bested by any of his ilk from the 80s when it comes to performing live, including Perry. The guy was the absolute fucking man and a monster performer.
Since 78 wrote:Ehwmatt wrote:The_Noble_Cause wrote:kgdjpubs wrote:I agree with you, but one thing Foreigner did right by getting Kelly Hansen is finding someone who's natural range is debatedly HIGHER than Lou Gramm's voice was before the medical problems.
No way. Maybe in his Hurricane days. Kelly can hit those glass shattering power notes when he has to - and does it quite well. But he keeps them in reserve and sings comfortably in his chest voice. Lou had a naturally high voice that would stop you cold in your tracks. We're talking a one-in-a-million set of pipes like Perry. There's a reason the new lineup has slowed certain songs down or done acoustic renditions, probably so Kelly has an easier time getting *up there* and hitting those highs. The difference between Lou in his prime and Kelly is most noticeable on Foreigner's last album. For much of "Can't Slow Down", Kelly sounds like Augeri on "Kiss me Softly" or something. It almost veers on boring and monotone. At it's worst, it sounds like a generic rocker voice. Kelly is the best replacement the band (and the fans) could have hoped for, but he's not higher pitched than vintage Lou.
I'm not sure vintage Lou is bested by any of his ilk from the 80s when it comes to performing live, including Perry. The guy was the absolute fucking man and a monster performer.
What kind of water are you drinking there in Cleveland? Both in their prime, Perry would destroy him. I'm not saying Lou wasn't a great singer, but please.
Ehwmatt wrote:Since 78 wrote:Ehwmatt wrote:The_Noble_Cause wrote:kgdjpubs wrote:I agree with you, but one thing Foreigner did right by getting Kelly Hansen is finding someone who's natural range is debatedly HIGHER than Lou Gramm's voice was before the medical problems.
No way. Maybe in his Hurricane days. Kelly can hit those glass shattering power notes when he has to - and does it quite well. But he keeps them in reserve and sings comfortably in his chest voice. Lou had a naturally high voice that would stop you cold in your tracks. We're talking a one-in-a-million set of pipes like Perry. There's a reason the new lineup has slowed certain songs down or done acoustic renditions, probably so Kelly has an easier time getting *up there* and hitting those highs. The difference between Lou in his prime and Kelly is most noticeable on Foreigner's last album. For much of "Can't Slow Down", Kelly sounds like Augeri on "Kiss me Softly" or something. It almost veers on boring and monotone. At it's worst, it sounds like a generic rocker voice. Kelly is the best replacement the band (and the fans) could have hoped for, but he's not higher pitched than vintage Lou.
I'm not sure vintage Lou is bested by any of his ilk from the 80s when it comes to performing live, including Perry. The guy was the absolute fucking man and a monster performer.
What kind of water are you drinking there in Cleveland? Both in their prime, Perry would destroy him. I'm not saying Lou wasn't a great singer, but please.
Don't get me wrong, bigger fan of Journey than Foreigner by a country mile. Gramm just kicks my ass everytime I watch him on YT from the mid 80s.
hoagiepete wrote:Hansen appears to be the best of the replacement singers I have heard. A perfect fit for Foreigner. I'm big fan of Lou's and reaching mid-life crisis stage, it saddens me to see all my old groups fall apart, but Hansen seems legit. I look forward to hearing them in September.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:kgdjpubs wrote:I agree with you, but one thing Foreigner did right by getting Kelly Hansen is finding someone who's natural range is debatedly HIGHER than Lou Gramm's voice was before the medical problems.
No way. Maybe in his Hurricane days. Kelly can hit those glass shattering power notes when he has to - and does it quite well. But he keeps them in reserve and sings comfortably in his chest voice. Lou had a naturally high voice that would stop you cold in your tracks. We're talking a one-in-a-million set of pipes like Perry. There's a reason the new lineup has slowed certain songs down or done acoustic renditions, probably so Kelly has an easier time getting *up there* and hitting those highs. The difference between Lou in his prime and Kelly is most noticeable on Foreigner's last album. For much of "Can't Slow Down", Kelly sounds like Augeri on "Kiss me Softly" or something. It almost veers on boring and monotone. At it's worst, it sounds like a generic rocker voice. Kelly is the best replacement the band (and the fans) could have hoped for, but he's not higher pitched than vintage Lou.
kgdjpubs wrote:I personally thought Arrival did a very good job muting Augeri's voice. He sounded MUCH better on Red13 and Generations.
kgdjpubs wrote:I haven't heard much of the Foreigner album, but from what I have heard, he is much lower pitched than he was previously. Maybe his voice has gone down a bit as he ages (or the Foreigner material was deliberately written lower-pitched), but those 2 cds I posted (the Unruly Child and Stuart Smith album) had him at least equal if not somewhat higher than Lou was generally. Granted, that was 10 years ago, so he may have lost some since then.
Return to Snowmobiles For The Sahara
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 18 guests