Moderator: Andrew
So, even if she didn't like him, that's herbrywool wrote:Because you've never given the guy an ounce of credit and do everything you can to dog the guy. Whatever. I sure won't change your mind. Just get tired of people griping over the slightest nuance and because he's not Steve Perry. Not fair to the guy.
brywool wrote:portland wrote:brywool wrote:portland wrote:brywool wrote:portland wrote:
Thanks for the update Bry......
I love it and YOU just can't stand it. All the more reason to love it. Jeez, there's no reason you can't like both or all the singers of this band. Jeez, just enjoy the music. Get over it already.
That was really not my point...I was referring to your need to say I told you so.
I am glad you love it! Enjoy!
And no matter how well the band does or does not do, you'll won't even entertain the fact that they've moved on. You have to give AP some credit. HUGE shoes to fill and he's doing a great job. He's not a replacement, duh. But what he brings is a great set of pipes. So I don't understand the hate.
I don't understand why you think I hate AP? I really don't hate anyone.
I get that we don't have the same opinion on the current line up...who knows it might grow on me.
I am going to buy Eclipse, just like I bought Revelation.....I might even attend a concert this time around.
My eye roll was more about the "I told you so" comment.
Because you've never given the guy an ounce of credit and do everything you can to dog the guy. Whatever. I sure won't change your mind. Just get tired of people griping over the slightest nuance and because he's not Steve Perry. Not fair to the guy.
portland wrote:brywool wrote:portland wrote:brywool wrote:portland wrote:brywool wrote:portland wrote:
Thanks for the update Bry......
I love it and YOU just can't stand it. All the more reason to love it. Jeez, there's no reason you can't like both or all the singers of this band. Jeez, just enjoy the music. Get over it already.
That was really not my point...I was referring to your need to say I told you so.
I am glad you love it! Enjoy!
And no matter how well the band does or does not do, you'll won't even entertain the fact that they've moved on. You have to give AP some credit. HUGE shoes to fill and he's doing a great job. He's not a replacement, duh. But what he brings is a great set of pipes. So I don't understand the hate.
I don't understand why you think I hate AP? I really don't hate anyone.
I get that we don't have the same opinion on the current line up...who knows it might grow on me.
I am going to buy Eclipse, just like I bought Revelation.....I might even attend a concert this time around.
My eye roll was more about the "I told you so" comment.
Because you've never given the guy an ounce of credit and do everything you can to dog the guy. Whatever. I sure won't change your mind. Just get tired of people griping over the slightest nuance and because he's not Steve Perry. Not fair to the guy.
I don't think I have been dogging the guy these days....I have been waiting to hear the new CD.
I actually have not been here much at all
brywool wrote:portland wrote:brywool wrote:portland wrote:brywool wrote:portland wrote:brywool wrote:portland wrote:
Thanks for the update Bry......
I love it and YOU just can't stand it. All the more reason to love it. Jeez, there's no reason you can't like both or all the singers of this band. Jeez, just enjoy the music. Get over it already.
That was really not my point...I was referring to your need to say I told you so.
I am glad you love it! Enjoy!
And no matter how well the band does or does not do, you'll won't even entertain the fact that they've moved on. You have to give AP some credit. HUGE shoes to fill and he's doing a great job. He's not a replacement, duh. But what he brings is a great set of pipes. So I don't understand the hate.
I don't understand why you think I hate AP? I really don't hate anyone.
I get that we don't have the same opinion on the current line up...who knows it might grow on me.
I am going to buy Eclipse, just like I bought Revelation.....I might even attend a concert this time around.
My eye roll was more about the "I told you so" comment.
Because you've never given the guy an ounce of credit and do everything you can to dog the guy. Whatever. I sure won't change your mind. Just get tired of people griping over the slightest nuance and because he's not Steve Perry. Not fair to the guy.
I don't think I have been dogging the guy these days....I have been waiting to hear the new CD.
I actually have not been here much at all
Same here, I bailed a while back and only check in now and then.
Michigan Girl wrote:So, even if she didn't like him, that's herbrywool wrote:Because you've never given the guy an ounce of credit and do everything you can to dog the guy. Whatever. I sure won't change your mind. Just get tired of people griping over the slightest nuance and because he's not Steve Perry. Not fair to the guy.
choice ...lord knows you've expressed your share of hate!! I get tired of your remarks, too!!
portland wrote:brywool wrote:portland wrote:brywool wrote:portland wrote:brywool wrote:portland wrote:brywool wrote:portland wrote:
Thanks for the update Bry......
I love it and YOU just can't stand it. All the more reason to love it. Jeez, there's no reason you can't like both or all the singers of this band. Jeez, just enjoy the music. Get over it already.
That was really not my point...I was referring to your need to say I told you so.
I am glad you love it! Enjoy!
And no matter how well the band does or does not do, you'll won't even entertain the fact that they've moved on. You have to give AP some credit. HUGE shoes to fill and he's doing a great job. He's not a replacement, duh. But what he brings is a great set of pipes. So I don't understand the hate.
I don't understand why you think I hate AP? I really don't hate anyone.
I get that we don't have the same opinion on the current line up...who knows it might grow on me.
I am going to buy Eclipse, just like I bought Revelation.....I might even attend a concert this time around.
My eye roll was more about the "I told you so" comment.
Because you've never given the guy an ounce of credit and do everything you can to dog the guy. Whatever. I sure won't change your mind. Just get tired of people griping over the slightest nuance and because he's not Steve Perry. Not fair to the guy.
I don't think I have been dogging the guy these days....I have been waiting to hear the new CD.
I actually have not been here much at all
Same here, I bailed a while back and only check in now and then.
Yeah well with the warm reception I get...it's really not worth it.
Michigan Girl wrote:Who asked YOU?!?! Portland didn't ask you what you thought, you didn't need
an invite
Majestic wrote:brywool wrote:portland wrote:brywool wrote:portland wrote:brywool wrote:portland wrote:
Thanks for the update Bry......
I love it and YOU just can't stand it. All the more reason to love it. Jeez, there's no reason you can't like both or all the singers of this band. Jeez, just enjoy the music. Get over it already.
That was really not my point...I was referring to your need to say I told you so.
I am glad you love it! Enjoy!
And no matter how well the band does or does not do, you'll won't even entertain the fact that they've moved on. You have to give AP some credit. HUGE shoes to fill and he's doing a great job. He's not a replacement, duh. But what he brings is a great set of pipes. So I don't understand the hate.
I don't understand why you think I hate AP? I really don't hate anyone.
I get that we don't have the same opinion on the current line up...who knows it might grow on me.
I am going to buy Eclipse, just like I bought Revelation.....I might even attend a concert this time around.
My eye roll was more about the "I told you so" comment.
Because you've never given the guy an ounce of credit and do everything you can to dog the guy. Whatever. I sure won't change your mind. Just get tired of people griping over the slightest nuance and because he's not Steve Perry. Not fair to the guy.
Brywool,
You're sure right about that. Not only is it unfair to Arnel, it's unfair to all concerned. The way I see it, Perry is doing what he wants to do, Journey, together with the help of Arnel, are doing what they want to do, Arnel is doing what he wants to do.... I loved Perry in Journey, and think he is one of the best, but I'm glad he's enjoying baseball games now, because I'd rather take in some shows and enjoy Journey turning out now music over the situation we had before Perry was finally replaced. And by the way, we all get that Arnel is not a tall white guy, but he sings better than most of them I've heard anyway and I'll take the big pipes over any other qualification any day. Funny thing about Arnel being Filipino, is that with the exception of Ross and Jonathan, has anybody ever noticed the pedigree of Journey members? There's a lot of ethnic blood there! I can't think of anything more American than that.
brywool wrote:Michigan Girl wrote:Who asked YOU?!?! Portland didn't ask you what you thought, you didn't need
an invite
Read the post MG. I posted. Then as Portland always seems to do, she throws in her little reply. So I didn't say anything to her until she did. As for the reply you quoted from me. I deleted it. IT was a bit harsh.
So please tell me what hateful posts have I made?
portland wrote:brywool wrote:Michigan Girl wrote:Who asked YOU?!?! Portland didn't ask you what you thought, you didn't need
an invite
Read the post MG. I posted. Then as Portland always seems to do, she throws in her little reply. So I didn't say anything to her until she did. As for the reply you quoted from me. I deleted it. IT was a bit harsh.
So please tell me what hateful posts have I made?
Bry.....my post was more directed at you coming in here and saying I told you so...it really was not directed at AP at ALL.
portland wrote:
I think your post was kind of inflammatory, it seemed to me you were looking for someone like me to answer? Maybe I am
wrong...but it was not my intention to dog anyone...you came to that conclusion on your own.
portland wrote:As for Dan's name calling I have been making a conscious effort to stay away from his posts...I know his opinion of me.
brywool wrote:Getting back to the clip- it was cool. Are there others from the same show?
portland wrote:brywool wrote:Boy these guys sure suck and the audience totally knows it. Man, in 3 months, Arnel will be toast and the band will be begging JSS to come back. Boy he's probably lipping. He just doesn't grab me and he's without soul
![]()
Hate to say I told you so gang, but the guy's got the goods and he is (just like last tour) KICKING A$$.
What am I saying, I LOVE to say I told you so.
This is how America used to react to Journey. It's very nice to see this again. It'd be great if SP was there, but he's not and I still love the band. Good luck to them.
Thanks for the update Bry......
You've done your fair share of Perry bashing, no posts in particular!!brywool wrote:Michigan Girl wrote:Who asked YOU?!?! Portland didn't ask you what you thought, you didn't need
an invite
Read the post MG. I posted. Then as Portland always seems to do, she throws in her little reply. So I didn't say anything to her until she did. As for the reply you quoted from me. I deleted it. IT was a bit harsh.
So please tell me what hateful posts have I made?
portland wrote:brywool wrote:Michigan Girl wrote:Who asked YOU?!?! Portland didn't ask you what you thought, you didn't need
an invite
Read the post MG. I posted. Then as Portland always seems to do, she throws in her little reply. So I didn't say anything to her until she did. As for the reply you quoted from me. I deleted it. IT was a bit harsh.
So please tell me what hateful posts have I made?
Bry.....my post was more directed at you coming in here and saying I told you so...it really was not directed at AP at ALL.
I think your post was kind of inflammatory, it seemed to me you were looking for someone like me to answer? Maybe I am
wrong...but it was not my intention to dog anyone...you came to that conclusion on your own.
As for Dan's name calling I have been making a conscious effort to stay away from his posts...I know his opinion of me.
Andrew wrote:Maui Tom wrote:never thought the C word would make it into this thread.....
It won't be tollerated again.
fredinator wrote:portland wrote:brywool wrote:Michigan Girl wrote:Who asked YOU?!?! Portland didn't ask you what you thought, you didn't need
an invite
Read the post MG. I posted. Then as Portland always seems to do, she throws in her little reply. So I didn't say anything to her until she did. As for the reply you quoted from me. I deleted it. IT was a bit harsh.
So please tell me what hateful posts have I made?
Bry.....my post was more directed at you coming in here and saying I told you so...it really was not directed at AP at ALL.
I think your post was kind of inflammatory, it seemed to me you were looking for someone like me to answer? Maybe I am
wrong...but it was not my intention to dog anyone...you came to that conclusion on your own.
As for Dan's name calling I have been making a conscious effort to stay away from his posts...I know his opinion of me.
Portland, I have to defend Brian here: you came out of nowhere one time and attacked me for no good reason. Brian has always been an excellent poster who contributes to the threads not only with his feelings about Journey but also his knowledge of music which in turn help make the threads interesting. I hope he doesn't bail anymore. Right, Brian, lol? Anyway, P, you really ought to edit yourself--MG, too, for that matter.
Andrew wrote:Maui Tom wrote:never thought the C word would make it into this thread.....
It won't be tollerated again.
I didn't think she would either.Maui Tom wrote:never thought the C word would make it into this thread.....
fredinator wrote: you really ought to edit yourself--MG, too, for that matter.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 12 guests