Tito wrote:I think the whole comment was bullshit. In fairness, the only one the b.s. meter went off throughout the interview. I think he was playing to the audience with that comment. I agree, I don't believe he hasn't heard the other two and I bet he doesn't know a Soto song. Soto never recorded with Journey. So, that means he has listened to Soto solo/other material? I doubt that and he hasn't heard the two who have recorded with Journey and been with them for 12 out of the last 13 years. C'Mon Man.
It’s not like Journey is all over the news, tv, etc., and don’t think he’s searching the web. If I were he, I would probably keep those “sound-alike” and their doings at a distance.
Yoda wrote:Let's look at this stuff in the right perspective. The guy admitted that he was very upset with Journey going on without him. I'm sure having the knowledge of hiring guys who would try to recreate the "Perry sound" in the vocals was something that got under his skin. .
Guess it would get under the skin of any true artist….
“I heard the new singer two weeks ago – he was amazing, and (I’m a very accomplished rock guitarist – 35 years,) there were times when I couldn’t tell it wasn’t Steve (with my eyes closed.) I’m a studio session player and have a great ear (I’m told.) Anywhen, here’s the comment – all that doesn’t matter, because STEVE DID IT FIRST – I can “copy” Eddie Van Halen, Steve Vai, etc. note for note (can’t tell it’s not them,) BUT…..THEY BLOW ME AWAY FOR THINKING OF “GOING THERE” IN THE FIRST PLACE – THAT’S WHERE STEVE’S GENIUS AND TALENT LIE. (Steve S. 8/11/2011)”
Michigan Girl wrote:[I just said this to Deb ...I'm sure he's heard them, I'm sure he isn't crazy about the whole impersonation/trying to sound alike thing SOME people think they had/have going. Jeff has his own soulful style, without having to try to capture something that is unreachable.
Kinda like the “sound-alikes” take away from the integrity of his hard-work, but may have some respect for the one that has his “own style” as he said. That is definitely “growth.” If they had hung in there with Jeff till “DSB” struck maybe people would have accepted his way of singing the songs or he could just stick the mic to the audience and let them sing.
Ehwmatt wrote:Translation: Jeff didn't have the range to draw comparisons akin to "closed my eyes and it sounded just like him!", thus Jeff threatened Perry the least. I'm not knocking JSS at all - love W.E.T. and like some of his solo stuff. But i don't see any other fair way to read the situation.
And neither do I “see any other fair way to read the situation” except this way: Augeri partook of lipping and Pineda partakes of mocking. What did JSS do? What threat was Augeri, and thought they got Pineda from YouTube with just singing talents. His words make perfect sense to me. Steve Perry seems to have a deep, kinda stubborn respect with integrity for music and artists. With that being said, I just cannot imagine his respectfully viewing a “sound-alike” or a “copycat” as an “incredible talent” no matter how talented YOU may think he is. It is just outside of the realms of artistic integrity and belongs in a “SNL” parody type thing. Would you have preferred he just say something to that effect? Did he say he never saw something coming? He seems to have expounded upon his reasons in a nice way. Brian May gave thumbs up to SP (“one in a million”) and to JSS.
You cannot blame an artist if he naturally sounds like another, but with Augeri that may not be and surely it is not with Arnel, for it seems he has been copying others hard-work for quite a while. That is an INSULT, especially to someone like SP I would think, so why expect him to toot either of those guys horns. Read Pineda’s interview from 2009, he knows the appearance of “note for note,” but did it anyway.
Steve Perry idolizes Sam Cooke, and as most artist do, take something from his idol’s style, but you don’t go in his former band and copy him. Can’t imagine SP EVER contemplating or respecting such. Guess you have to look at the “situation” from the eyes (MINE) of one who just may not think very much of any artist whose aim is to deliberately sound-alike or copy. Where is the originality? Surprise, surprise that you, seemingly an artist, do not share that view.
“They worked hard to make it their own.” SP