AR wrote:Enigma869 wrote:AR wrote:
And the Sox should be embarassed that it happened considering how many more resources they have.
Last I checked the Twins won 63 games last year. One bad contract.
The Red Sox and others will always be able to afford to eat those.
And last I checked, the Red Sox finished in third place the last two seasons! While I'm not a fan of the current system in baseball, claiming the team with the number one payroll automatically wins is a dopey argument in all sports, because the reality is that it almost NEVER happens that way!
Dopey? Hardly. Simple logic.
Give the GM in Minnesota a huge payroll and see what happens. Big market teams can be lazy and bloated and spend there way out of anything. Sure the Sox finished 3rd, but they will always be in contention simply because of resources.
I will say this, not only would I like to see a salary cap, but almost more importantly a salary floor. As much as I argue about mid market teams at a competitive disadvantage, there are greedy owners like in Pittsburgh and Baltimore who don't even try. For them it's more profitable to lose.
Good debate between you and John. I sympathize with your side of the argument, obviously. The Sox and Yanks may not win the WS every single year, but you can almost always count on them competing.
You can't do the same in small markets once you make one or two bad moves. For instance, the Indians: we were a game away from the World Series in 2007 and everything blew up in our faces. The Travis Hafner contract became an albatross that plagues us still today. To a lesser extent, Sizemore was killing us too. Enter the Cliff Lee/Sabathia infamous back-to-back Cy Young trades to ease our cheap ownership's pain. And like you said, THAT's the problem. It's basically a vicious cycle for MOST small/mid market teams: you somehow get lucky, develop some players who get really good on your dime, you have a window of competitiveness, and then they're all gone to the big markets. The Twins are an outlier.
A salary floor's a good idea. Our ownership in Cleveland is absurdly cheap. They run it like a regular business, which as a pro sports owner you just can't do. They also are simply not wealthy enough to own a pro sports team, especially in the MLB. Yeah, they're rich, but not THAT rich.