steveo777 wrote:Not sure I agree with you with my "bolded". Jeremey had recent vocal problems and I feel that touring Journey's catalog would have made that much worse. This is not to neg on Jeremey.
I never said he'd last, though I'm sure one could make the argument that he could given his own rigorous touring schedule with Frontiers.
steveo777 wrote:Also don't agree with you on the musicianship of this album. Neal should be envious. This band is everything Journey should be right now....but they aren't. Jeremey is creating a familiar kind of magic, while not a sound alike, this is a band that takes us down a very similar path.
Have you done a complete 180 on
Eclipse? It wasn't too long ago that you were praising the album for its musicianship, I believe. Whatever your beef with the Schon-Salahi media frenzy may be, you shouldn't indulge in Loon-inspired soccer mom-perpetuated revisionist history that tends to pop up when someone makes an ass out of themselves in the media.
For me, the only stand out performance on this album is Jeremey himself. Fortunately, his singing and writing are strong enough to make it work, but the band itself is in no way Journey-class.
'Nothing was bigger for Journey than 1981’s “Escape” album. “I have to attribute that to Jonathan coming in and joining the writing team,” Steve Perry (Feb 2012).'