Rolie or Pineda

by **Don** » Mon Sep 03, 2012 11:06 am

While Cain helped elevate the writing of the group to where the lyrics became more than simple melody carriers, Rolie's time with the band did produce some great harmonic numbers before layering became all the fashion in the 80s.

As there are already a minimum of four pre-Captured tracks in the setlist every night, do you guys want more of that (Precious Time, WLAL, JTSW) or would you rather they add an equal number of Rev/Eclipse songs to balance it out?

by **RedWingFan** » Tue Sep 04, 2012 1:46 am

Had to go with Rolie tracks just to avoid any possible "Damn, I thought I had to fart but some Eclipse came out" seeping into the show.

by **jestor92** » Tue Sep 04, 2012 2:46 am

Rolie any day over some of the worst music the band has ever released.

by **tater1977** » Tue Sep 04, 2012 2:52 am

Rollie because of his experience, history & polish..

by **scarab** » Tue Sep 04, 2012 3:30 am

Rolie,

Great stuff there, pre and post Perry.

The new Journey has been paint by the numbers or Neal solo material.
Nothing that will stand the test of time.

To hear next with Neal/Deen, or Deen singing sweet and simple would be worth the price of admission.

by **JRNYMAN** » Tue Sep 04, 2012 6:07 am

RedWingFan wrote:Had to go with Rolie tracks just to avoid any possible "Damn, I thought I had to fart but some Eclipse came out" seeping into the show.

+1

by **JRNYMAN** » Tue Sep 04, 2012 6:13 am

scarab wrote:Rolie,

Great stuff there, pre and post Perry.

The new Journey has been paint by the numbers or Neal solo material.
Nothing that will stand the test of time.

To hear next with Neal/Deen, or Deen singing sweet and simple would be worth the price of admission.

Never thought about Deen doing Sweet and Simple.... that would be good. I'd like to hear him doing WYLAW and Happy to Give.

by **Starrider** » Tue Sep 04, 2012 8:36 am

Voted for more Rolie. It would be even better if Gregg was back in the band. I doubt he wants to get back to the grueling life of a touring musician, but even if he played a few shows here and there, I would be willing to lay down some serious cash to see it.

There is some great stuff on Evolution, Infinity, and Departure that needs to get played. I could go for hearing "Of a Lifetime" as well, but don't know if the band would be willing to reach that far back in time.

by **Michigan Girl** » Sat Sep 08, 2012 12:57 am

wow ...I don't know what shocks me most Pineda era rec'd 10 votes
or Pineda era rec'd ONLY 10 votes. I would love to see this put to a
vote on the band's website ...course, they'd have to care about what
their fans wanted to hear in order to do something that advantageous/courageous.
Do they?! or have they already taken this journey?!? :wink:

lmao@ RWF

Rolie era all the way as long as they are doing it justice ...so
why aren't the Pineda era voters loud and proud?!?

by **Eric** » Sat Sep 08, 2012 2:49 am

There are two other choices, that I might be inclined to lean towards.

Augeri era
Non hit Perry era

by **Majestic** » Sat Sep 08, 2012 10:23 am

Pineda.

I love the Rolie era stuff, but some of the live versions of Revelations from that tour were amazing and I'd love to see it come back. Not so much for Eclipse, because, although I like the album, most of what I've heard doesn't translate well live.

by **Gideon** » Sat Sep 08, 2012 10:38 am

Majestic wrote:Pineda.

I love the Rolie era stuff, but some of the live versions of Revelations from that tour were amazing and I'd love to see it come back. Not so much for Eclipse, because, although I like the album, most of what I've heard doesn't translate well live.

I'd kill to hear "Wildest Dream" again.
Not to mention the fact that the Rolie-era material is going to shred Arnel's voice quicker than anything with those stratospheric money notes.

Website · by **steveo777** » Sat Sep 08, 2012 10:52 am

Journey didn't really hit it's stride until the Perry / Cain era. Not sure many people are going to respond to those songs any better than they do the post Perry material.

by **jestor92** » Sat Sep 08, 2012 12:08 pm

steveo777 wrote:Journey didn't really hit it's stride until the Perry / Cain era. Not sure many people are going to respond to those songs any better than they do the post Perry material.

Sit a bunch of people in an arena and Journey plays anything from Pineda or Augeri's era and the band plays Perry/Rollie Era songs. I can guarentee you more people will know and respond better to the Perry/Rollie era songs.

Let's see Perry Rollie Era
Feeling that Way/Anytime
Patiently
Just The Same Way
Too Late
Where Were You
Line Of Fire
Stay Awhile
Walks Like A Lady

Oh yeah can't forget

Wheel In the Sky
Lights
Lovin, Touchin, Squeezin
Anyway You Want It

vs

Anything from Pineda or Augeri Era

I do believe Rollie/Perry era gets more of a reception

by **Don** » Sat Sep 08, 2012 12:19 pm

While not Top 40, Rolie Era songs Just The Same Way, Feeling That Way/Anytime, Stay Awhile/Good Morning Girl, Walks Like A Lady broke into the top 100 on the singles charts and received plenty of Airplay back in the day so there is some familiarity for the older audience members with those tunes. Not to mention, Line Of Fire and Where Were You were concert staples up through the Escape tour.

Website · by **steveo777** » Sat Sep 08, 2012 1:32 pm

jestor92 wrote:
steveo777 wrote:Journey didn't really hit it's stride until the Perry / Cain era. Not sure many people are going to respond to those songs any better than they do the post Perry material.

Sit a bunch of people in an arena and Journey plays anything from Pineda or Augeri's era and the band plays Perry/Rollie Era songs. I can guarentee you more people will know and respond better to the Perry/Rollie era songs.

Let's see Perry Rollie Era
Feeling that Way/Anytime
Patiently
Just The Same Way
Too Late
Where Were You
Line Of Fire
Stay Awhile
Walks Like A Lady

Oh yeah can't forget

Wheel In the Sky
Lights
Lovin, Touchin, Squeezin
Anyway You Want It

vs

Anything from Pineda or Augeri Era

I do believe Rollie/Perry era gets more of a reception

The poll said "Rolie era tracks". My bad. My opinion is what it would be like with Pre-Perry songs, with Rolie.

by **Archetype** » Sun Sep 09, 2012 12:06 am

Starrider wrote:
I could go for hearing "Of a Lifetime"

I think it would be an awesome addition to the set. Fuck the casual fans.

by **Starrider** » Sun Sep 09, 2012 12:36 am

Archetype wrote:
Starrider wrote: I could go for hearing "Of a Lifetime"

I think it would be an awesome addition to the set. Fuck the casual fans.

It was great to hear it on the 2005 tour, but it just isn't the same with JC singing it instead of Gregg. Talk about an awesome guitar solo, too.

"Of a Lifetime" live in Japan, 10/11/1980:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oHQL2yVPDaw

by **SF-Dano** » Sun Sep 09, 2012 1:40 am

If they happen to do a 40th anniversary tour similar to the 30th, I would love to hear the title track - Look Into the Future played live. The mellow beginning that just builds to the jam at the end of the song - cool tune that is very overlooked.

by **Michigan Girl** » Tue Sep 11, 2012 7:28 am

jestor92 wrote:
steveo777 wrote:Journey didn't really hit it's stride until the Perry / Cain era. Not sure many people are going to respond to those songs any better than they do the post Perry material.

Sit a bunch of people in an arena and Journey plays anything from Pineda or Augeri's era and the band plays Perry/Rollie Era songs. I can guarentee you more people will know and respond better to the Perry/Rollie era songs.

Let's see Perry Rollie Era
Feeling that Way/Anytime
Patiently
Just The Same Way
Too Late
Where Were You
Line Of Fire
Stay Awhile
Walks Like A Lady

Oh yeah can't forget

Wheel In the Sky
Lights
Lovin, Touchin, Squeezin
Anyway You Want It

vs

Anything from Pineda or Augeri Era

I do believe Rollie/Perry era gets more of a reception

Thank you!!

MR

Rolie or Pineda

What would you like to hear more of in addition to the Dirty Dozen?

Rolie or Pineda

Who is online