The_Noble_Cause wrote:Monker wrote:AIP is not attempting to be an anthem. That is absolutely ridiculous.
CBS radio called AIP "A classic Journey
anthem."
Andrew on this site called AIP "the uplifting feel good
anthem Anything Is Possible."
So clearly I'm not alone.
Of course not. People can agree and you can all be wrong.
AIP is not an anthem.
"Be Good to Yourself", "Change for the Better", "Don't Stop Believin", "Never Too Late", "Anything Is Possible" - All of these songs, with titles that serve as inspirational phrases, can be described as anthems.
Yeah, with the exception of DSB, they can also be described as mediocre pop songs that not many people care about and are very much NOT anthems.
You seem to have a narrow definition of an anthem as something like Queen's "We Will Rock You" or Leppard's "Pour Some Sugar on Me." But I never said AIP was a fist pounding "rock anthem." It's a breezy mellow rock tune with an anthemic motivational chorus. It's an anthem.
That's not what an anthem is. Nobody at a sporting event is yelling out the words to AIP as their anthem. DSB - yes. If you want these songs to be YOUR anthem, fine...but they are not anthems in general. That's just silly nonsense you are arguing here and you are turning into a debate over the definition of a word so you don't have to admit you are wrong. That is fucking boring and stupid.
Monker wrote:No way Journey would try to write a song in the mold from anything off of ROR, with Schon in the band.
Cain has gone to this well before and not just on ROR.
AIP does not sound like BGTY. It sounds more like IBAWY. A pop song.
Monker wrote:No, too conspiracy theory for me. What you are saying is about as likely as "Chain of Love" trying to capitalize on the popularity of "Lord of the Rings' by writing similar lyrics. It's just made up bullshit.
Except the lyrics in City of Hope EXPLICITLY include "Never Stop Believin" multiple times. You mean to say this is a coincidence? It's an obvious reference to Don't Stop Believin, whose success brought the band back into the spotlight. Arnel's biographical documentary is even titled, Don't Stop Believing. Another coincidence? No tin foil hat required to see what's going on here.
If Chain of Love" has explicit lyrics about Galadriel, Tom Bombadil, and Mt. Doom, I missed that. That's such a pathetic argument, even for you.
one ring to bring them all
and in the the darkness, bind them.
It's the chain of love that finds me
the chain of love that binds me
Reads about as close as your DSB crap...and the second verse goes on about "voices in my head that try to rule me". Clearly this is the "Chain of Power" and if Neal gets that chain back he'll cover all of the lands with a second darkness.
"Never stop believing" may be a sorta nod to DSB, but it's not trying to use its popularity for anything...it can't because it would have to be heard on the radio first.
Monker wrote:DSB is not a simplistic pop song with almost plagiarized lyrics.
Cain is on record multiple times saying that the "midnight train" lyrics in DSB were a "homage" to Glady's Knight's Midnight Train to Georgia. As the saying goes, one man's homage is another man's rip-off. So there's nothing new here. And of course, DSB is a pop rock song. That goes without saying. I guess you think it's Hardcore Pornogrind Death Metal?

[/quote]
AIP -
When you shoot for the moon
and you miss your mark
you still end up so high among the stars
Les Brown
"Shoot for the moon and if you miss you will still be among the stars."
Dude, I noticed that plagiarism when I first heard the song. It's OBVIOUS Jonathan knew the one line and set it to a melody...much different than just using "midnight train" and the imagery. Les Brown deserves a partial writing credit.