Moderator: Andrew
The_Noble_Cause wrote:Who likes the album the way it is?
Who here wishes that they didn't tinker with it and left "ATL" and "OTY" on there?
I agree with part of your statement Eric. But leaving it alone means keeping BackTalk on the album...arguably, and this was a thread, Journey's worst tune ever...Abitaman wrote:Frontiers is better as is. BUT if they had left it alone, it may have given Escape more of a run for sales.-ERIC
SF-DANO wrote:I know I'm in the minority on this one, but I never really thought "Only the Young" was that great a song. It is good, but I like "Troubled Child" more.
Just my opinion.
NealIsGod wrote:I would have kept Only the Young and Ask the Lonely and dumped Rubicon and BackTalk. That would put the album on par with ESC4P3, IMO.
I agree luke. Those two tracks are classics, though I do like Rubicon and Troubled Child a LOT.lukeisgod wrote:hi, its my favorite journey cd /album and though I like it the way it is..it would be hands down the best they ever did with those 2 tracks added..IMHO sometimes, when u mess with success u fuck it up..in this case, I'd say no..the songs fit perfectly with the rest of the cd....
just my 2 cents...
augeri rocks!!!!!
chi-town crazy mar'tay![]()
cubby69 wrote:ATL and OTY are both good songs in their own right. But Troubled Child is an incredible tune, much much better. Back Talk needed to be there only to show that this version of the band(Cain) did more than just write love songs. Lord knows we have enough of Cains sappy sugary lovey dovey shit songs.
Red13JoePa wrote:Just got done a spin. First time in a while.
Side 2 is nothing short of a goddam tour-de-force. This record is very very close to being as good as ESC4P3.
amaron wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:Just got done a spin. First time in a while.
Side 2 is nothing short of a goddam tour-de-force. This record is very very close to being as good as ESC4P3.
I'd agree if it weren't for Back Talk. IMO, Journey's worst song, only seconded by Dead or Alive.
NealIsGod wrote:amaron wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:Just got done a spin. First time in a while.
Side 2 is nothing short of a goddam tour-de-force. This record is very very close to being as good as ESC4P3.
I'd agree if it weren't for Back Talk. IMO, Journey's worst song, only seconded by Dead or Alive.
So wouldn't those two songs cancel each other out, amaron? You place Frontiers #2, after ESC4P3?
Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 1 guest