Indyjoe wrote:Wheels Of Fyre wrote:Indyjoe wrote:Wheels Of Fyre wrote:Blue Radio Girl wrote:Wheels Of Fyre wrote:So if it is a literal story then why didn't Adam and Eve die when they ate of the tree...?
If you take the story for the purposes in which it was meant (to tell a story and give a lesson, since it is from the Torah) then they did die, as in their life as it was promised them was stripped away and they died of that life and were exiled into a new one. Death and birth and rebirth isn't always cut and dry. Open your mind to alternative explainations instead of trying to force your perception of inaccuracy on those who would think otherwise.
No. God told them very directly: IN THAT DAY YOU SHALL DIE.
What is the problem with the answers? They were kicked out of the garden, separated from God. Death, the process begun.
Genesis 2:17
But of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, thou shalt not eat of it: for in the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die.
So God was lying?
No. Adam and Eve DID die THAT DAY. They died OF THE SPIRIT and were born OF THE FLESH. Before "eating" they were both "naked and unashamed" and after "eating" they were "naked and ashamed". Everyone goes through this - it's called puberty!
Then Jesus came along and said that one must be BORN AGAIN OF THE SPIRIT - baptism - the ritualistic cleansing/washing away of the flesh.
To read this story as a LITERAL and HISTORICAL one is to misread it!
No God doesn't lie. I don't understand the puberty comment - Adam was a man.
I believe that I am not misreading or misunderstanding the Scriptures.
This has made for an interesting discussion. Not an easy one to have behind a keyboard! I disagree with you, however wherever this "conversation" should end, I wish you well Wheels of Fyre!!

And that was my intention when I recommended that book to you.
~Wendy
I have nothing but the best intentions, too!
All I'm saying is that for me the story of Adam and Eve is about "growing up".
When we're children - before puberty - we're innocent. We're in the spirit. As boys and girls we're "naked and unashamed". Then we "eat of the tree" which is to say we reach puberty and lose our innocence to the ways of the flesh. In other words we die of the spirit and are born into the flesh. In so doing we're removed from innocence and Paradise.
Why do people search for the Garden of Eden? What do they expect to find there? How silly! The Gardn is right where you stand IF you stand IN THE SPIRIT. If you're NOT in the spirit then you'll be logged into MapQuest for a very, very long time!
Ultimately, we're ALL Adam and Eve. They're not our Great, Great, Great X 1,000,000 Grandparents. They're us and we are them.
Recently my family and I were visiting with our friends who are going to be the God Parents of our children. Everybody's Catholic except me. I'm entirely non-denominational. Despite being Catholic my friend believes that the rib story is about how God is really an alien that performed a kind of cloning procedure by removing Adam's rib! Well, if that brings comfort then I suppose that's as good an understanding as any! It doesn't with him, though.
I believe that the goal is to listen with the "right" ears and it will bring comfort and enliven one's life.
There's a teacher who talks about listening with giraffe ears! His name is Marshall Rosenburg and he travels the world teaching non-violent communication. He teaches that non-violent speaking and listening comes from the heart therefore he chose the giraffe to represent his teaching as the giraffe has the largest heart of all land animals. He also chose the jackal to represent violence. I had the opportunity to see him in Cleveland many years ago and even ask him some questions. His presentation is very fun. He uses giraffe and jackal puppets and has conversations between them that are very entertaining. He's one of many that are - in very subtle ways - carrying on Jesus' tradition of "those with ears to hear" His website is:
http://www.cnvc.org/
I believe that if we accept biblical stories as they are spoon fed to us by tradition then we're not listening with the right ears. I'd say that we're not listening at all. Tradition is fine to slap us in the ass as we begin our ventures however at some point in time we must also find our own ways.