Red13JoePa wrote:1) No way Wharton lips. No how.
4) he's hit or miss live but does have an incredible voice.
Vince Neil is in a special category, but I can't consider him a great vocalist. Why special? His sound helped shape the L.A. metal scene in the 80's, and is really identifiable with that era. But he's always had trouble in the studio -- I remember reading how on "Theater of Pain", he had immense trouble singing "City Boy Blues" (it still came out, "City BAA Blues"). Watch his "Remaking Vince Neil" special and watch all the trouble Desmond Child had with him in the studio, and Vince himself admits that there is usually something on every song that he has trouble getting right. But enough work in the studio, and you get the results you hear on the albums.
Live, he's MUCH better when he's not drinking, and horrendous when he is. Even sober, he is notorious for skipping words in the songs, "Sugar... Sweet... Packages... Candycane" to help preserve his voice in a show. Vince never considered him a great voice.
Doesn't mean you can't love Vince Neil's voice, though, and I do! I just don't consider him a great vocalist.