Moderator: Andrew
JSS Rocks! wrote:Nicely done!
Don wrote:Borderline Schlock. Thank god the rest of the record (minus a few songs) manages to overcome this high theater piece in maintaining the overall premise of being a competent rock album.
steveo777 wrote:Don wrote:Borderline Schlock. Thank god the rest of the record (minus a few songs) manages to overcome this high theater piece in maintaining the overall premise of being a competent rock album.
All you have to do is right click and delete it before you burn your cd.
steveo777 wrote:conversationpc wrote:Worst song on the album, easily, in my opinion.
The same boat doesn't float everyone. I love the song. It's in my top 4.
conversationpc wrote:steveo777 wrote:conversationpc wrote:Worst song on the album, easily, in my opinion.
The same boat doesn't float everyone. I love the song. It's in my top 4.
That's because you suck.
![]()
steveo777 wrote:conversationpc wrote:Worst song on the album, easily, in my opinion.
The same boat doesn't float everyone. I love the song. It's in my top 4.
YoungJRNY wrote:In my opinion, Tantra was the sleeper for me that hit me when I least expected it. I just think it packs a big punch and is practically the closest thing on the whole album when following the Journey ballad guideline. I think it's very nicely written and obviously very well sung. Just a good change-up that gives a nice feel to the entire CD.
jrnyjetster wrote:I'll have to give Tantra a few more listens, but so far, my least favorite track.
Don wrote:Borderline Schlock. Thank god the rest of the record (minus a few songs) manages to overcome this high theater piece in maintaining the overall premise of being a competent rock album.
Liquid_Drummer wrote:steveo777 wrote:conversationpc wrote:Worst song on the album, easily, in my opinion.
The same boat doesn't float everyone. I love the song. It's in my top 4.
Not crazy about the Disney sounding intro/outro but damn !! The rest of the song is probably Arnels best vocal work yet. Parts of the verse have almost the same feel as something to hide but for just a moment. Really dont get the twinkle toes intro/outro. The middle section though is just bad ass IMHO.
conversationpc wrote:Worst song on the album, easily, in my opinion.
Bingo ...too emotional/too much vibrato trying to come up w/soul thatKISSNTIME wrote:Don wrote:Borderline Schlock. Thank god the rest of the record (minus a few songs) manages to overcome this high theater piece in maintaining the overall premise of being a competent rock album.
+1. Tantra and "To Who It May Concern" are easily my two least favorite tunes.
I know where they were wanting to go with Tantra but they never got there. What could have been this version of Journey's own "Wheel In The Sky" instead comes off as Broadway-style Schlock. It's like a mix of a wedding song, Broadway and a National Anthem. Overly dramatic, way too slow. Arnel's singing is way too emotional and he drastically needs to hold back on the vibrato.
My wife walked into my office when this was playing and said "Oh my God, what the HELL is that!?" I told her it was the new Journey and she replied, "Ouch!"
I couldn't argue.
Michigan Girl wrote:Bingo ...too emotional/too much vibrato trying to come up w/soul thatKISSNTIME wrote:Don wrote:Borderline Schlock. Thank god the rest of the record (minus a few songs) manages to overcome this high theater piece in maintaining the overall premise of being a competent rock album.
+1. Tantra and "To Who It May Concern" are easily my two least favorite tunes.
I know where they were wanting to go with Tantra but they never got there. What could have been this version of Journey's own "Wheel In The Sky" instead comes off as Broadway-style Schlock. It's like a mix of a wedding song, Broadway and a National Anthem. Overly dramatic, way too slow. Arnel's singing is way too emotional and he drastically needs to hold back on the vibrato.
My wife walked into my office when this was playing and said "Oh my God, what the HELL is that!?" I told her it was the new Journey and she replied, "Ouch!"
I couldn't argue.
he just caaaaan't quite reach ... could've been beautiful!!
Majestic wrote:Michigan Girl wrote:Bingo ...too emotional/too much vibrato trying to come up w/soul thatKISSNTIME wrote:Don wrote:Borderline Schlock. Thank god the rest of the record (minus a few songs) manages to overcome this high theater piece in maintaining the overall premise of being a competent rock album.
+1. Tantra and "To Who It May Concern" are easily my two least favorite tunes.
I know where they were wanting to go with Tantra but they never got there. What could have been this version of Journey's own "Wheel In The Sky" instead comes off as Broadway-style Schlock. It's like a mix of a wedding song, Broadway and a National Anthem. Overly dramatic, way too slow. Arnel's singing is way too emotional and he drastically needs to hold back on the vibrato.
My wife walked into my office when this was playing and said "Oh my God, what the HELL is that!?" I told her it was the new Journey and she replied, "Ouch!"
I couldn't argue.
he just caaaaan't quite reach ... could've been beautiful!!
Asside from not liking Arnel's performance much, how do you feel about the song? I think, if Perry keeps up with Journey at all, this is the one song on Eclipse he'd be dying to sing. Man, would I love to hear that! This song is right up Perry's alley. I think Arnel sings it great though, and I hear the soul in his voice and think he sells it in a sincere way.
Michigan Girl wrote:Majestic wrote:Michigan Girl wrote:Bingo ...too emotional/too much vibrato trying to come up w/soul thatKISSNTIME wrote:Don wrote:Borderline Schlock. Thank god the rest of the record (minus a few songs) manages to overcome this high theater piece in maintaining the overall premise of being a competent rock album.
+1. Tantra and "To Who It May Concern" are easily my two least favorite tunes.
I know where they were wanting to go with Tantra but they never got there. What could have been this version of Journey's own "Wheel In The Sky" instead comes off as Broadway-style Schlock. It's like a mix of a wedding song, Broadway and a National Anthem. Overly dramatic, way too slow. Arnel's singing is way too emotional and he drastically needs to hold back on the vibrato.
My wife walked into my office when this was playing and said "Oh my God, what the HELL is that!?" I told her it was the new Journey and she replied, "Ouch!"
I couldn't argue.
he just caaaaan't quite reach ... could've been beautiful!!
Asside from not liking Arnel's performance much, how do you feel about the song? I think, if Perry keeps up with Journey at all, this is the one song on Eclipse he'd be dying to sing. Man, would I love to hear that! This song is right up Perry's alley. I think Arnel sings it great though, and I hear the soul in his voice and think he sells it in a sincere way.
There's more to it than just the vox ...I think AP is a great singer and has great vox ...
I don't think he'll ever be one of my favs because he lacks what I like/demand/crave
in my singers ...This LP is not about the vox, ...I'm reviewing
this LP based on the lyrics/musicianship/originality/ the whole unit!!
Don't give a diddly~doo about AP and his ability to fill in, we've been there~done that!
It's already been established that the shoes of the great one will never be filled ...
why do that shit again?!?!
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 25 guests