StevePerryHair wrote:Did you watch the YouTube Dan?
Yes, and though I disagree with her punishments, I don't find them to be in violation of the law.
StevePerryHair wrote: It's CLEAR torture to me.
Torture is defined as "the act of inflicting excruciating pain" and I think you're reaching a bit here. Cold water simply
can't do that.
Hot water could! I'm not a proponent of what she did, but I will commend her for clearly outlining why he was in trouble, what he did wrong, what he's supposed to do and why his actions led to his punishments. There's actually a lot of good going on in that video. And I know of kids his age that would have stood in that shower with their arms folded and their faces stoic ... just to prove a point. And I was one of them!
StevePerryHair wrote:There is no excuse to discipline a child this way.
Perhaps not, but until I see a law that clearly outlines what she did as wrong, I'll give her the benefit of the doubt.
StevePerryHair wrote:Our most helpless have NO rights and it's disgusting!!! Look how old he is!! This makes me angry
His admission shows an understanding of what's right and wrong, and he simply
chose not to do the right thing. And his mother disciplined him in a way that she deemed appropriate. I'd be more concerned about kids that misbehave in class and are sent home to indifferent parents. Or worse yet, parents that defend the actions of those kids! This lady is trying to exact change, and while she's arguably exploiting her son to get on TV, something tells me that she just wants him to behave properly. Those cold showers will be a distant memory very soon. I'd be interested to see how her other 5 kids turned out.
That would probably tell us a lot.